home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
Text File | 1995-02-26 | 61.0 KB | 1,556 lines |
- TF01
- 3,Yesterday's Enterprises
- 4,by Tim Smith
-
- SEASON FOUR
- -------------
-
- After the ground breaking third season, fans expectations were high.
- But would the fourth season be able to repeat the critical and
- commercial success of its predecessor?
-
- It was a season where a number of achievements would be made. For
- starters there was the conclusion to Star Trek's first ever
- cliffhanger ending to a season. Then there was the seventy ninth
- episode ("Remember Me") which equalled Classic Trek's tally, the
- eightieth episode ("Legacy") which broke that tally, and TNG's one
- hundredth episode, the season finale, "Redemption". The seasons
- eighty seventh episode, "Devil's Due" also achieved the highest ever
- Nielsen rating upto that pointing - a feat that would only be broken
- with the last ever TNG episode "All Good Things...". Ironically, in
- fact it was originally a script for the proposed "Star Trek II"
- series which would have starred the Classic Trek crew.
-
- Michael Piller returned to lead the writing staff, and Rick Berman's
- increased involvement with the show was shown by his promotion to
- Executive Producer. Also promoted, was Ronald D. Moore who now shared
- the title of Executive Story Editor with Joe Menosky. Other
- promotions were those of David Livingston who became Producer and
- Wendy Neuss who became Associate Producer. Jeri Taylor co-wrote the
- teleplay of "Suddenly Human" and went onto becoming Supervising
- Producer.
-
- Some forty writers were involved with the show and included such
- first time writers as Rick Berman, Brannon Braga, Peter Allan Fields,
- and Joe Menosky. To compliment the forty writers were fifteen
- directors. They included the only female director of Trek (an
- incongruity that remained until TNG's seventh season) Gabrielle
- Beaumont, Jonathan Frakes who directed a further two episodes and
- first time TNG director Patrick Stewart.
-
- The series garnered eight Emmy nominations (including co-nominees)
- for its fourth season, all of which were technical, and four of which
- were for the season opener "Best of Both Worlds, Part II". It won
- only two, for sound mixing series ("Best of Both Worlds, Part II")
- and sound editing series ("Best of Both Worlds, Part II").
- Surprisingly, no acting nominations were forthcoming, even for
- Patrick Stewart performance in the season opener. It did go to a show
- a continuing prejudice against Star Trek, but it did not stop the
- audience from enjoying the show.
-
-
- Episode One - "Best of Both Worlds, Part II"
- --------------------------------------------
-
- Written by Michael Piller
- Directed by Cliff Bole
-
- Airdate: 24/9/90
-
- Stardate: 44001.4
-
- Guest Cast: Lt. Cmdr. Shelby - Elizabeth Dennehy
- Admiral Hanson - George Murdock
- Chief O'Brien - Colm Meaney
- Guinan - Whoopi Goldberg
-
- Commander Riker orders Worf to open fire on the Borg ship, but the
- weapon has no effect and the Borg resume their course towards
- Earth...
-
- After just over three months of waiting, fans finally discovered the
- fate of Picard, the Enterprise and indeed, the entire Federation. The
- episode was visually impressive, and included an accomplished set
- piece with the rescue of Picard/Locutus. On almost every level it is
- faultless. The special effects were amazing, the costumes, music and
- set design all of a feature film standard, but perhaps the most
- salient aspect was the acting. Patrick Stewart was stunning in his
- dual role and should have received an Emmy nomination for his
- efforts. He was not the only one to show he could act though.
- Jonathan Frakes, Whoopi Goldberg, and Brent Spiner also gave
- exemplary performances.
-
- The only fault with it, and this is something that plagued all the
- resolutions to the cliff hanger season finales, is that the ending
- seems a little rushed. The tension is built up very effectively for
- the first thirty six minutes and then a three minute sequence, where
- the Borg are ordered to "sleep" and self destruct in the process
- breaks that tension like a balloon that's been suddenly deflated.
- After the preceeding eighty or so minutes I was expecting something
- more. It is really a case of close but no cigar.
-
- Best moment: The rescue of Picard/Locutus. Guinan's discussion with
- Riker.
-
- Man of the moment: Patrick Stewart and William Riker.
-
- Best Line: "Picard is still here with us, in this room. If he had
- died, it would have been easier, but he didn't. They took
- him from us a piece at a time. Did he ever tell you why
- we're so close? Well let me just say that our relationship
- is beyond friendship, beyond family, and I will let him go
- and you must do the same."
-
- Rating: Very good.
-
-
- Episode Two - "Family"
- ----------------------
-
- Written by Ronald D. Moore
- Directed by Les Landau
-
- Airdate: 1/10/90
-
- Stardate: 44012.3
-
- Guest Cast: Robert Picard - Jeremy Kemp
- Marie Picard - Samantha Eggar
- Rene Picard - David Tristan Birkin
- Sergei Rozhenko - Theodore Bikel
- Helena Rozhenko - Georgia Brown
- Chief O'Brien - Colm Meaney
- Guinan - Whoopi Goldberg
- Jack Crusher - Doug Wert
-
- Recovering from his ordeal at the hands of the Borg, Picard returns
- to his home town of Labarre, France to face perhaps his greatest
- challenge of all...
-
- This episode was made at the insistence of Michael Piller, who
- managed to persuade Rick Berman that to ensure credibility, Picard
- must be seen to recover from the events depicted in the two previous
- episodes. It was a brave decision to go ahead with "Family" as it's
- completely devoid of any action, or any other of the elements
- normally associated with a typical episode. However, it's probably
- one of the best ever entries out of the entire seven season run of
- The Next Generation.
-
- No only do we meet Picard's brother (played to perfection by Jeremy
- Kemp), sister-in-law and nephew (played by David Tristan Birkin, who
- would later appear as the young Picard in "Rascals") but we also meet
- Worf's foster parents, Sergei and Helena Rozhenko. Georgia Brown
- would reprise her role in the fifth season episode "New Ground but it
- wouldn't be until the seventh season that we would meet his foster
- brother. The much talked about Jack Crusher was seen in an
- ineffectual holodeck scene, the only downside to "Family". Doug Wert
- would play the character twice more, once in the fifth season (for
- two seconds) and once in the seventh season. Even O'Brien gets in on
- the act. We learn his first and middle names and hear of a visit his
- father made to the Enterprise.
-
- The acting in this episode is powerful stuff, with the scenes between
- Patrick Stewart and Jeremy Kemp showing what quality actors they both
- are. If it hadn't been for the holodeck scene this would have been
- the perfect episode.
-
- Best moment: Picard's breakdown in the vineyard
-
- Man of the moment: Jeremy Kemp
-
- Best line: "Well part of him may feel that way, but there's another
- part of him that I've seen. The part that comes in and
- drinks prune juice. The part that looks out the window
- towards home. But he's not looking towards the Klingon
- Empire, he's looking towards you.
-
- Rating: Very good.
-
-
- Episode Three - "Brothers"
- --------------------------
-
- Written by Rick Berman
- Directed by Rob Bowman
-
- Airdate: 8/10/90
-
- Stardate: 44085.7
-
- Guest cast: Miles O'Brien - Colm Meaney
-
- A little boy lies desperately ill, but before the Enterprise can get
- him to a Starbase, Data takes control of the ship and changes its
- course...
-
- The first proper episode after the Borg saga was something of a tour
- de force for Brent Spiner as he got play three roles - Data, Lore and
- their creator Noonian Soong. It must be the first time in Trek
- history that an actor has played his own character, his brother and
- their father! Certainly, Spiner shows just how good he is. He is
- helped by effective makeup and some clever camera techniques, but in
- the end the effectiveness of the episode depends on his ability to
- persuade us that he is playing three different roles.
-
- Unfortunately the quality of the script does not match up to the
- quality of Spiner's acting. There is an effective set up where Data
- takes control of the ship and diverts it to the new destination, and
- a touching scene where Lore discovers that Soong himself is dying,
- but in the final analysis nothing much actually happens in the end. I
- was left thinking "is that it?"!
-
- Best moment: Data's escape from the Enterprise
-
- Man of the moment: Brent Spiner
-
- Best line: "The only we knew we'd come out of warp was by looking out
- a window"
-
- Rating: Good
-
-
- Episode Four - "Suddenly Human"
- -------------------------------
-
- Written by John Whepley, Jeri Taylor and Ralph Phillips
- Directed by Gabrielle Beaumont
-
- Arrdate: 15/10/90
-
- Stardate: 44143.7
-
- Guest cast: Jono - Chad Allen
- Captain Endar - Sherman Howard
-
- Whilst investigating a Talarian vessel that is in distress, an away
- team from the Enterprise discover that one of the injured Talarians
- is, in fact, Human...
-
- Originally meant to be an episode about child abuse "Suddenly Human"
- ends up being a bit of an indifferent entry. The real plot is about
- whether Jono should be returned to his human relatives (and thus, his
- true heritage) or to the Talarian captain who raised him since he was
- a baby. It's a difficult question and one to which either answer
- could be justified but "Suddenly Human" fails to live up to the
- dramatic possibilities posed by this question.
-
- Chad Allen (now starring in "Dr. Quinn" with Jane Seymour) guests
- stars as Jono and does alright but his role is too much like his
- character in "St. Elsewhere" to be anything interesting.
-
- On a trivia note, Picard is seen playing racquetball with Jono. A
- similar court would appear in DS9 when it was revealed that both
- Doctor Bashir and Chief O'Brien play the sport.
-
- Best moment: When Wesley discovers how to wear a Banana Split!
-
- Person of the moment: The viewer (for managing to stay awake)
-
- Best line: "This is no doubt a variation on pie in the face."
- "Now do you see why it's funny?"
- "No, Sir. But I will take your word for it. This is very
- amusing"
-
- Rating: Poor
-
-
- Episode Five - "Remember Me"
- ----------------------------
-
- Written by Lee Sheldon
- Directed by Cliff Bole
-
- Airdate: 22/10/90
-
- Stardate: 44161.2
-
- Guest cast: Chief O'Brien - Colm Meaney
- Commander Dalen Quaice - Bill Erwin
- The Traveller - Eric Menyuk
-
- After greeting an old friend on board the Enterprise, Doctor Crusher
- discovers he is missing. But it is only the beginning as one by one
- each crew member vanishes...
-
- The Next Generation's seventy ninth episode is all about not
- forgetting things close to us. A timely reminder to those fans of
- Star Trek who only watch The Next Generation.
-
- Gates McFadden manages very well, portraying Crusher's increasing
- confusion and fear as the crew disappear and she is the only person
- aware of it happening. All the rest of the cast have little more than
- supporting roles but do well with what they have.
-
- In a couple of nice nods to continuity both Kosinski (from the first
- season "Where No One Has Gone Before") and Doctor Selar (from the
- second season episode "The Schizoid Man") are both given a mention.
- In fact, it's a pity that Doctor Selar would never actually appear
- again, although Suzie Plakson, the actress who played her, would make
- a further appearance as K'Ehleyr two episodes later.
-
- This was very much a bottle show, so the costumes, and sets remained
- unchanged, but there was a very effective vortex that was superbly
- created bu Robert Legato and his crew.
-
- Eric Menyuk returned as the Traveller, but unfortunately only appears
- for the final act. His next appearance as the Treveller (in the
- seventh season episode "Journey's End") was so brief that it prompted
- Menyuk to comment that the next time the Traveller appeared the would
- just hold up a picture of him!
-
- Best moment: The second time Doctor Crusher is almost sucked into the
- vortex.
-
- Woman of the moment: Gates McFadden
-
- Best line: "Mr. Worf, Chief of Security. Big guy who never smiles."
-
- Rating: Good
-
-
- Episode Six - "Legacy"
- ----------------------
-
- Written by Joe Menosky
- Directed by Robert Scheerer
-
- Airdate: 29/10/90
-
- Stardate: 44215.2
-
- Guest cast: Ishara Yar - Beth Toussaint
- O'Brien - Colm Meaney
-
- The Enterprise rushes to the aid of two Federation engineers who have
- crashed on Turkana IV, the homeworld of former comrade, Tasha Yar...
-
- Beth Toussaint plays Tasha Yar's younger sister, Ishara. There was
- talk of Denise Crosby playing the role, but she would return in
- another role at the end of the season, but sensibly the producers
- chose Toussaint for the role of Ishara. She is very good in the part
- and manages to give this character a sympathetic quality.
-
- Ironically, although Tasha Yar is not in this episode, we learn alot
- about her past. Her parents were killed soon after Ishara's birth,
- and Tasha asked Ishara to come with her when she left Turkana IV, but
- Ishara refused as she considered the cadre her family. Picard then
- asked for her to be transferred to the Enterprise after he saw her
- perform an act of bravery.
-
- This is also a "Data" episode to a certain extent. He feels some sort
- of attachment to Ishara and Spiner is very subtle in portraying
- Data's reaction to the actions of Ishara.
-
- The sets used as the underground caverns of Turkana IV are, in fact,
- redressed from the Borg ship interiors set, but it is recogniseable
- as such due to the excellent job done by Richard James.
-
- Best moment: Data and Riker's discussion about trust.
-
- Woman of the moment: Beth Toussaint.
-
- Best line: "Without trust there's no friendship, no closeness, none
- of the emotional bonds that makes us who we are."
-
- Rating: Good
-
-
- Episode Seven - "Reunion"
- -------------------------
-
- Written by Thomas and Jo Perry, Ronald D. Moore, Brannon Braga and
- Drew Deighan.
- Directed by Jonathan Frakes
-
- Airdate: 5/11/90
-
- Stardate: 44246.3
-
- Guest cast: K'Ehleyr - Suzie Plakson
- Gowron - Robert O'Reilly
- Duras - Patrick Massett
- K'mpec - Charles Cooper
- Alexander - Jon Steuer
-
- Ambassador K'Ehleyr arrives on the Enterprise with some shocking news
- - K'Mpec, the leader of the Klingon Empire has been fatally poisoned
- by one of the two people vying for the leadership.
-
- "Reunion" was the third part of the Klingon saga that started with
- with the second season episode "The Emissary" and would conclude with
- "Redemption, Part II" although elements and characters from it would
- continue into all three remaining seasons of The Next Generation, an
- episode of DS9 and even the new movie, "Generations".
-
- It is full, and I mean full of Klingon rituals and weapons and their
- time honoured traditions of honour. We get to see inside a Klingon
- attack cruiser (although we don't see much of it!) and we learn of
- such things as the bat'leth. This mean looking weapon would have
- prominent roles in future episodes including "Parallels", "First
- Born" and DS9s contribution "Blood Oath".
-
- With such a distinguished list of guest stars the acting can not help
- but be outstanding. Charles Cooper returns to make his third and
- final appearance as a Klingon (his previous appearances were as
- General Korrd in "Star Trek V" and K'Mpec in "Sins of the Father")
- and joining him in also his final bow is Patrick Massett as Duras.
- Robert O'Reilly is the only one of the guest stars who would return
- (as Popeye, sorry, I mean Gowron) as K'Ehleyr is murdered and the of
- Alexander would be played by Brian Bonsall in future episodes.
-
- Jonathan Frakes once again shows what a superb director he his by his
- assured handling of all the action. He would go on to direct several
- more episodes including one more in the fourth season ("The
- Drumhead") and one of the highlights of the fifth season "Cause and
- Effect". His directing association with Star Trek has continued as he
- has just directed the second episode of Deep Space Nine's third
- season ("The Search, Part II") and hopes to direct future episodes of
- both Deep Space Nine and Voyager.
-
- Best moment: Worf discovering K'Ehleyr dying
-
- People of the moment: Charles Cooper and Suzie Plakson
-
- Best line: "You have never seen death? Then look and always remember"
-
- Rating: Very good
-
-
- Episode Eight - "Future Imperfect"
- ----------------------------------
-
- Written by J. Larry Carroll and David Bennett Carren
- Directed by Les Landau
-
- Airdate: 12/11/90
-
- Stardate: 44286.5
-
- Guest cast: Tomalok - Andreas Katsulas
- Ethan - Chris Demetral
- Ogawa - Patti Yasutake
- Minuet - Carolyn McCormick
-
- Commander Riker collapses whilst on an away team mission. When he
- awakes, it is sixteen years into the future, and he is Captain of the
- Enterprise...
-
- "Future Imperfect" is a clever episode in more ways than one. The
- plot is interesting, and it contains two major twists that are a
- genuine surprise the first time round. It also affords Jonathan
- Frakes an all too rare oppurtunity to show he can act. He does a good
- job in showing Riker's concern over being a good father to "Jean
- Luc". His trombone playing makes another appearance and we also learn
- that he likes fishing and that he uses the Curtis Creek holodeck
- program. We also see his birthday being celebrated in typical style
- (although we don't actually learn his birthdate).
-
- Patti Yasutake makes her first appearance as Nurse Ogawa. She would
- also appear a further three times in the fourth season, and would
- continue to appear in the remaining seasons of the Next Generation.
-
- As with "Yesterday's Enterprise" there are many little changes made
- to denote the "future". Included among them are new communicators
- (which would also be seen in the seventh season episode "Parallels"),
- a female Klingon crew member, a Ferengi ensign and Geordi without his
- Visor (which would also be seen in the seventh season episodes
- "Interface", "Parallels" and "All Good Things...").
-
- Andreas Katsulas made his third appearance as Tomalok. He would go on
- to try for the role of Odo in Deep Space Nine (losing out to Rene
- Auberjonois), play Ambassador G'Kar in Babylon 5 and make a final
- appearance as Tomalok in The Next Generation finale "All Good
- Things...". Carolyn McCormick also reprised her role of Minuet (from
- the first season episode "11001001") in a brief cameo.
-
- Best moment: When Riker realises that the future Enterprise is not
- all it seems.
-
- Man of the Moment: Jonathan Frakes
-
- Best line: "I said shut up! As in close your mouth and stop talking!"
-
- Rating: Good
-
-
- Episode Nine - "Final Mission"
- ------------------------------
-
- Written by Kacey Arnold-Ince and Jeri Taylor
- Directed by Corey Allen
-
- Airdate: 19/11/90
-
- Stardate: 44307.3
-
- Guest cast: Dirgo - Nick Tate
-
- Wesley is accepted into Starfleet Academy, and Captain Picard asks
- him to accompany him on one final mission. However, neither of them
- realise just how final it might be...
-
- Ironically, Wesley's swan song would end up being one of his finest
- episodes. Hw would appear in four more episodes, two in the fifth
- season ("The Game" and "First Duty") and two in the seventh season
- ("Parallels" and "Journey's End"), but "Final Mission" would be the
- last time he would appear as one of the regular cast.
-
- Not only do we see three fine performances from Stewart, Wheaton and
- Nick Tate (who used to play Alan Carter in Space 1999) but an
- excellent use of lighting and camera angles. Some of the dialogue
- descends into soap opera at times but on the whole it is well
- written.
-
- As for trivia, to show how relatively primitive Captain Dirgo's
- technology is, he uses an old style phaser previously seen in use in
- the Star Trek movies and the shuttle hull is made from Duranium
- (previously mentioned in the third season episodes "A Matter of
- Perspective" and "Hollow Pursuits"), and the Hydronalin used to
- combat the radiation that the Enterprise crew encounter was first
- mentioned in the original Star Trek episode "The Deadly Years".
- Picard also sings (very badly) the song he and his brother sang
- earlier on in the season in "Family" and mentions Boothby, the
- grounds keeper at the Academy to Wesley. In return Wesley talks of
- the previous shuttle journey he and Picard had taken together which
- occurred in the second season episode "The Samaritan Snare".
-
- Best moment: The shuttle's crash.
-
- Man of the moment: Marvin Rush, the Director of Photography.
-
- Best line: "Oh, I envy you, Wesley Crusher. You're at just at the
- beginning of the adventure."
-
- Rating: Average.
-
-
- Episode Ten - "The Loss"
- ------------------------
-
- Written by Hilary J. Bader, Alan J. Adler and Vanessa Green
- Directed by Chip Chalmers
-
- Airdate: 31/12/90
-
- Stardate: 44358.9
-
- Guest cast: Guinan - Whoopi Goldberg
-
- The Enterprise is being drawn into a cosmic string, and cannot break
- free. At the same time, and for no apparant reason, Counsellor Troi
- loses her empathic powers...
-
- This would be the only episode during the fourth season that would
- concentrate on Troi in any significant way., which is a bit of a
- shame considering just how bad it is. Its weakness does not lie with
- any of the actors. Indeed, Marina Sirtis is incredibly good, and
- Jonathan Frakes and Whoopi Goldberg give able support. However, they
- are hampered by a script that has more ham in it than Porky Pig,
- particularly the scenes where Troi is counselling a recently bereaved
- crew member.
-
- Captain Picard's love of horse riding continues when he invites Riker
- to joinhim in the Kabul river holodeck programme. His horse riding
- skills would also play his part in the sixth season episode "Starship
- Mine" and in the new movie "Generations".
-
- We also learn that like the Ferengi, the Breen can not be read by
- Betazoids and that a Betazoids empathic abilities lie within the
- cerebral cortex.
-
- Best moment: The scene between Guinan and Troi (the first time the
- characters had been on screen together!)
-
- Woman of the moment: Marina Sirtis
-
- Best line: "The way people change. How they start to treat you
- differently, They walk on eggshells around you, sometimes
- they avoid you altogether. Sometimes they become
- overbearing! Reach out a helping hand to the blind woman."
-
- Rating: Awful.
-
-
- Episode Eleven - "Data's Day"
- -----------------------------
-
- Written by Harold Apter and Ronald D. Moore
- Directed by Robert Wiemer
-
- Airdate: 7/1/91
-
- Stardate: 44390.1
-
- Guest cast: O'Brien - Colm Meaney
- Keiko Ishikawa - Rosalind Chao
- Ambassador T'Pel - Sierra Pecheur
- Commander Mendak - Alan Scarfe
-
- Commander Data records a typical day on the Enterprise...
-
- This episodes was memorable for many reasons. It was the first time
- there had been a wedding on the Enterprise since the original Star
- Trek episode "Balance of Terror". Indeed the words that Picard uses
- are exactly the same as those that Kirk used. It was also the first
- time that such an episode (a day in the life) was done in the history
- of Star Trek. According to Data a typical day contained four
- birthdays, two transfers, four promotions, two chess tournaments, a
- secondary school play, the Hindu Festival of Lights, the birth of
- Juareze's baby and, of course, Miles and Keiko's wedding.
-
- Seeing the ship, and it's crew through Data's eyes is highly
- enjoyable, and effective. The log Data is making is for Commander
- Bruce Maddox who was last seen two years previously in the second
- season episode "The Measure of a Man". We see Data's dancing lesson
- in a beautifully played scene with Doctor Crusher in a holodeck
- recreation of the studio where she had her first lesson. However the
- most important event concerned with Data is the screen debut of his
- cat, Spot.
-
- The events depicted in the episode concerning the "defection" of
- Ambassador T'Pel would be refered to ten episodes later in "The
- Drumhead" and the idea of the Romulans using a fake plea for peace
- would also resurface in the fifth season two parter "Unification". A
- quotation used here by Data concerning Sherlock Holmes would also be
- repeated virtually word for word in Star Trek VI.
-
- The Andorians get their first mention since the third season, and we
- also get to see the barber shop, the arboretum and a replication
- centre for the first time.
-
- Best moment: The wedding scene.
-
- Man of the moment: Brent Spiner
-
- Best line: "My hair does not require trimming you lunk head."
-
- Rating: Average.
-
-
- Episode Twelve - "The Wounded"
- ------------------------------
-
- Written by Jeri Taylor, Stuart and Sara Charno and Cy Chermak
- Directed by Chip Chalmers
-
- Airdate: 28/1/91
-
- Stardate: 44429.6
-
- Guest cast: O'Brien - Colm Meaney
- Captain Maxwell - Bob Gunton
- Keiko O'Brien - Rosalind Chao
- Gul Macet - Marc Alaimo
-
- A renegate starship, the USS Pheonix, is attacking Cardassian ships
- and threatening the fragile peace treaty between the Federation and
- the Cardassian Empire...
-
- This sees the introduction of the Cardassians to the world of Star
- Trek. The making is striking as are the uniforms (although they would
- be changed in subsequent episodes). They are just the icing on the
- cake though, as the real power of the characters are the actors who
- play them. Marco Rodrigues who had appeared as Paul Rice in the first
- season episode "Arsenal of Freedom" played Glinn Telle, and Marc
- Alaimo, who had played Selay in the first season episode "Lonely
- Among Us" and a Romulan in the first season finale "The Neutral Zone"
- played his third alien Gul Macet. Alaimo would also play a human
- character in the finale to season five "Time's Arrow" before moving
- onto the recurring role of Gul Dukat in Deep Space Nine.
-
- Already alot of the background to the Cardassians is revealed in "The
- Wounded". The title of Gul is the Cardassian rank equivalent to that
- of a Starfleet captain. A Glinn is the equivalent to that of a
- lieutenant. The type of warship most commonly used is the Galor
- class. In fact, it would not be until Deep Space Nine's second season
- that we would see a different class of Cardassian ship. There has
- also been a peace treaty that has lasted about one year after years
- of conflict. Picard himself has had dealings with the Cardassians in
- the past as when he was captain of the Stargazer he had to flee from
- a Cardassian warship.
-
- We also learn more about O'Brien. Whilst Keiko is cooking him
- plankton loaf, he would much prefer to eat his traditional family
- dish of potato casserole. He used to be the tactical officer on the
- USS Rutledge, serving under Captain Maxwell. Of course there is also
- the introduction of a new class of ship, with the Nebula class USS
- Pheonix.
-
- However, the idea of Starfleet officers acting the way Captain
- Maxwell does betrays Gene Roddenberry's guidelines for Star Trek. As
- I've said before, Starfleet is not a military organisation and
- Starfleet officers would not attack any kind of enemy ship, station
- or colony.
-
- A very similar plot, of a starship sent to capture a renegade ship
- that has been attacking Cardassians has resurfaced almost four years
- later as the plot for the pilot of Voyager.
-
- Best moment: O'Brien and the Cardassian officer in Ten Forward.
-
- Man of the moment: Bob Gunton
-
- Best line: "I'd never killed anything before. When I was a kid, I'd
- worry about swatting a mosquito. It's not you I hate
- Cardassian, it's what I became because of you."
-
- Rating: Average.
-
-
- Episode Thirteen - "Devil's Due"
- --------------------------------
-
- Written by Philip Lazebruck and William Douglas Lansford
- Directed by Tom Benko
-
- Airdate: 4/2/91
-
- Stardate: 44474.5
-
- Guest cast: Ardra - Marta Dubois
- Doctor Clarke - Paul Lambert
- Jared - Marcello Tubert
-
- The Enterprise is called to rescue scientists from Ventax III where
- the people are rioting. But why has a once peaceful world turned to
- confusion..?
-
- This is the episode that broke the show's record for the Neilsen
- ratings. It's original Trek origins can be seen in that it has only
- two major roles for two of the regular cast, i.e. instead of Spock
- there is Data and instead of Kirk, there is Picard. LaForge also has
- a supporting role where once it would have been Scotty. The rest of
- the crew have literally nothing to do. That said Spiner and Stewart
- are terrific, and Marta Dubois (who had once tried out for the role
- of Troi) is a convincing Ardra.
-
- The teaser (a scene from "A Christmas Carol") is very funny and
- allows Spiner to step out of the Data for a brief time.
-
- We learn that the Klingons first made contact with Ventax II twenty
- years previously to the episode and that although they have no devil
- in their beliefs (stated in the original Star Trek episode "The Day
- of the Dove") they do have a creature called Fek'lhr who guards a
- place known as Grethor where Klingons who have died dishonoured are
- sent.
-
- This is really the Star Trek equivalent of fast food. There is no
- great depth or substance to it, but it's enormous fun and if you take
- it for what it is, highly enjoyable.
-
- Best moment: The teaser.
-
- Man of the moment: Charles Dickens
-
- Best line: "You may be a bit of undigested beef, a blot of mustard, a
- crumb of cheese, a fragment of underdone potato. Why,
- there's more gravy than grave about you."
-
- Rating: Good
-
-
- Episode Fourteen - "Clues"
- --------------------------
-
- Written by Bruce D. Arthurs and Joe Menosky
- Directed by Les Landau
-
- Airdate: 11/2/91
-
- Stardate: 44502.7
-
- Guest cast: O'Brien - Colm Meaney
- Guinan - Whoopi Goldberg
- Nurse Ogawa - Patti Yasutake
-
- The Enterprise is investigating a mysterious planet when it is thrown
- through a wormhole. At first they think that they have been
- unconscious for a mere thirty seconds, but the evidence points to a
- whole day of their lives unaccounted for and somehow, Data seems to
- be involved...
-
- "Clues" offered the viewer the first chance in approximately two
- years to see the Dixon Hill program, in a frivolous teaser. Doctor
- Crusher is also shown growing Diomedian Scarlet Moss, and Worf
- leading a Tai Chi class in which Deanna Troi takes part. In
- retrospect, it may also be viewd as the beginning of the Worf/Troi
- relationship.
-
- A wormhole makes a second Next Generation appearance, and we learn
- that Data had previously encountered such an anomoly on board his
- previous ship, the USS Trieste. Star Trek fans would have to wait a
- further two years before they would see another wormhole, the gateway
- to the Gamma Quadrant in Deep Space Nine.
-
- The plot is not only interesting but offers fine performances from
- Brent Spiner and Patrick Stewart, as Picard tries to discover just
- what Data is hiding, and how he is involved in the mystery. However,
- whilst the explanation as to why Data refuses to tell Picard exactly
- what has happened and why is sound, Picard's inability to trust Data
- seems a little amiss. Indeed, why Data does not just ask Picard to
- trust him and leaves matters well alone is also surprising. Mind you,
- if he had done, the episode would have been over rather quickly.
-
- Best moment: Worf's Tai Chi class.
-
- Man of the moment: Brent Spiner.
-
- Best line: "Which would you place first? The welfare of a single
- individual, or that of the entire crew?"
-
- Rating: Good
-
-
- Episode Fifteen - "First Contact"
- ---------------------------------
-
- Written by Dennis Russell Bailey, David Bischoff, Joe Menosky, Ronald
- D. Moore and Marc Scott Zicress
- Directed by Cliff Bole
-
- Airdate: 18/2/91
-
- Stardate: Unknown
-
- Guest cast: Mirasta - Carolyn Seymour
- Durken - George Coe
- Krola - Michael Ensign
-
- Commander Riker goes missing whilst on an undercover mission on a
- planet about to venture into the stars...
-
- Whenever a large amount of writers are credited on an episode it's
- usually a sign that it's a bit of a stinker. "First Contact" is a
- prime example of this. The basic premise of "First Contact" is a
- complete contradiction of Gene Roddenberry's guidelines for Star
- Trek. Indeed it is known that Gene had a lot of problems with this
- episode and who can blame him? Starfleet would not only never send
- people undercover into such a society, but it would certainly never
- beam two of its officers directly into the centre of that society's
- government. It's a flagrant breaking of the Prime Directive!
-
- Riker's attempt to escape is also poorly written, with his sexual
- encounter with one of the women at the hospital where he is held
- captive played for laughs. In fact, it is again a breach of the Prime
- Directive and nothing but an excuse for Bebe Neuwith to make a guest
- appearance and a very cheap laugh. Would a Starfleet officer really
- act this way?
-
- There really is virtually nothing to commend about this episode.
- Carolyn Seymour makes her second Next Generation appearance. She
- played a Romulan in the second season episode "Contagion" and would
- also play a Romulan in the excellent sixth season episode "Face of
- the Enemy". Michael Ensign would also make a further Star Trek
- appearance, this time in the first season DS9 episode "The Forsaken"
- as a Vulcan ambassador.
-
- The only trivia worthy of mention is that Picard opens the bottle of
- wine that his brother gave him (from earlier on in the season in
- "Family"). A bit of a waste if you ask me!
-
- Best moment: You've got to be joking!
-
- Woman of the moment: Carolyn Seymour.
-
- Best line: "I hate to think how you would judge us based on our
- popular music and entertainment."
-
- Rating: Awful.
-
-
- Episode Sixteen - "Galaxy's Child"
- ----------------------------------
-
- Written by Maurice Hurley and Thomas Kartozian
- Directed by Winrich Kolbe
-
- Airdate: 11/3/91
-
- Stardate: 44614.6
-
- Guest cast: Leah Brahms - Susan Gibney
- Guinan - Whoopi Goldberg
-
- One of the designers of the Enterprise, Leah Brahms, visits the ship,
- whilst the Enterprise "adopts" a new life form...
-
- This is the first Geordi episode of the season and reintroduces the
- character of Leah Brahms, first seen in the third season episode
- "Booby Trap". It is also another of those failed romances that Geordi
- seems to be so good at.
-
- LeVar Burton and Susan Gibney play off each other beautifully, and
- it's a pity that Gibney did not return for a third episode. Her
- character, or at least a "Leah" is mentioned as being married to
- Geordi in the future timeline in TNG's final episode, and the events
- in "Galaxy's Child" would be referred to two seasons later in
- "Relics". However, perhaps the most disappointing news is that at one
- point she was considered for the role as Janeway in "Voyager" but not
- chosen!
-
- The secondary plot stands up well, and doesn't fall into the usual
- trap of just being there to fill in the time. This time it is the
- dramatic focal point of the episode and dovetails nicely into the
- main plot. It is also a strong contrast to the preceeding episode in
- that Picard's attitude towards the dilemma is exactly hoe Gene would
- have wanted it to be.
-
- Best moment: When "Junior"'s friends arrive to protect him.
-
- Woman of the moment: Susan Gibney
-
- Best line: "We are out here to explore. To make contact with other
- lifeforms. To make peaceful relations, nut not to
- interfere. And absolutely not to destroy, and yet look at
- what we have just done."
-
- Rating: Good
-
-
- Episode Seventeen - "Night Terrors"
- -----------------------------------
-
- Written by Pamela Douglas, Shari Goodhartz and Jeri Taylor
- Directed by Les Landau
-
- Airdate: 18/3/91
-
- Stardate: 44651.2
-
- Guest cast: O'Brien - Colm Meaney
- Keiko - Rosalind Chao
- Guinan - Whoopi Goldberg
-
- The Enterprise discovers the USS Brittain marooned in space with all
- but one of it's crew dead. But as Troi tries to question the survivor
- the crew discover that they too are trapped...
-
- This is one of those episodes that has some excellent moments which
- tend to be overshadowed by its weak moments. All of the regular cast
- are more than fine, but are let down by poor performances form the
- actors in minor roles.
-
- Of course there are the unconvincing sequences where Troi flies in
- her dreams. When talking with others about this episode these scenes
- always come up for criticism and on watching this episode again, it's
- easy to see why. Marina Sirtis looks uncomfortable and gives the
- appearance of auditioning for a production Peter Pan rather than
- playing Deanna Troi.
-
- Another point that strikes me after reviewing "Night Terrors" is how
- much like the first season spisode "The Naked Now" it is. The crew
- come across a ship trapped in space with all its crew dead by there
- own hands. Then one by one the same fate begins to happen to the
- Enterprise crew. See what I mean? However "Night Terrors" is better
- than "The Naked Now" but then, that wouldn't be difficult.
-
- There are good points to all this though. The Borg are given a
- cursory mention, the nighmares that each crew member has are quite
- effective and Patrick Stewart and Gates McFadden are particularly
- good.
-
- Best moment: The two ships escaping.
-
- People of the moment: Patrick Stewart and Gates McFadden.
-
- Best line: "To admit you're afraid gives you strength."
-
- Rating: Average
-
-
- Episode Eighteen - "Identity Crisis"
- ------------------------------------
-
- Written by Brannon Braga and Timothy DeHaas
- Directed by Winrich Kolbe
-
- Airdate: 25/3/91
-
- Stardate: 44664.5
-
- Guest Cast: Lt. Cmdr. Leitjen - Maryann Plunkett
- Nurse Ogawa - Patti Yasutake
-
- One by one, the members of an away team that Geordi was on, year
- previous to his joining the Enterprise, begin to disappear until only
- Lieutenant Commander Leitjen and himself are left...
-
- The second Geordi episode of the season is a bit of a corker that
- offers an all too rare glimpse into his past as well as a gripping
- science fiction mystery. The set designer, Gary SSpeckman and makeup
- supervisor Michael Westmore must be congratulated for their quite
- outstanding work on this episode. Indeed, Westmore and his team
- received a well deserved Emmy nomination for their work but for some
- bizarre reason did not win.
-
- The episode is also full of nice continuity touches. In the logs from
- the original away team's mission they all wear the old style uniforms
- and Geordi sports his old command division lieutenant uniform. One of
- the shuttles stolen by an errant away team member is form the USS
- Aries, the ship that Riker turned down in the second season episode
- "The Icarus Factor" and Nurse Ogawa's surname is finally mentioned.
-
- The atmosphere and growing tension is built up by the sets, make up
- and direction form Winrich Kolbe (his second episode episode of the
- season after "Identity Crisis") who has gone on to direct further
- Next Generation and DS( episodes, as well as Voyager's pilot episode
- "Caretaker", and the acting abilities of LeVar Burton and Maryann
- Plunkett.
-
- Best moment: The Enterprise's initial away team investigation.
-
- Man of the moment: Michael Westmore
-
- Best line: "I know what's going on inside you. The war you're
- fighting with yourself. Your humanity slipping away. The
- instinct to run: it's overpowering. But they know how to
- beat it now Geordi. Look at me! I've come back Geordi. Let
- me take you back too."
-
- Rating: Very good
-
-
- Episode Nineteen - "Nth Degree"
- -------------------------------
-
- Written by Joe Menosky
- Directed by Robert Legato
-
- Airdate: 1/4/91
-
- Stardate: 44704.2
-
- Guest cast: Lt. Barclay - Dwight Shultz
- Einstein - Joe Morton
-
- Whilst repairing the Argus array, Lieutenant Barclay is struck down
- by a mysterious probe. He awakes with an intelligence far exceeding
- that of his crewmates, but will it prove a danger to them..?
-
- Dwight Shultz makes a welcomed return as Lieutenant Barclay, the
- slightly neurotic crew member who was previously addicted to holodeck
- programmes in the third season episode "Hollow Pursuits". Dwight is
- perfect in the role and it is indeed a pity that the rumours of him
- becoming a regular cast member never amounted to anything. Whilst he
- wouldn't appear in the fifth season, he would appear twice in the
- sixth ("Ship in a Bottle" and "Realm of Fear") and once in a wasted
- cameo in the seventh season episode "Genesis" (probably, no
- definately, one of the worst ever Star Trek, not just TNG, episodes
- ever!)
-
- The Argus array would also play a part in "Parallels" (from the
- seventh season) and Doctor Crusher's drama club would be mentioned or
- seen in one fifth season episode ("Disaster") and two sixth season
- episodes ("A Fistful of Data's" and "Frame of Mind"). Albert
- Einstein, or at least the holographic image of him would also return
- in the final episode of season six "Descent". He would again be
- played by Jim Morton.
-
- Perhaos the most interesting thing about this episode is the fact
- that the Enterprise journeys to the centre of the galaxy and meets a
- strange energy type being. Sound familiar? In fact, when I first saw
- this episode at a convention the audience gave an audible gasp as
- they took it to be a sequel to Star Trek V. It's a shame that there
- wasn't some kind of explanation or continuity nod to that film.
-
- Best moment: The scene between Reg and Deanna in the teaser.
-
- Man of the moment: Dwight Shultz.
-
- Best line: "You just spent the entire night arguing grand unification
- theories with Albert Einstein."
-
- Rating: Good.
-
-
- Episode Twenty - "Qpid"
- -----------------------
-
- Written by Ira Steven Behr and Randee Russell
- Directed by Cliff Bole
-
- Airdate: 22/4/91
-
- Stardate: 44741.9
-
- Guest cast: Vash - Jennifer Hetrick
- Sir Guy - Clive Revill
- Q - John de Lancie
-
- Q transports the crew to Sherwood Forest, where Picard is Robin Hood
- and he is the Sherriff of Nottingham...
-
- This sees both the return of Jennifer Hetrick as Vash (from the third
- season's "Captain's Holiday") and John de Lancie as Q in what was his
- fifth appearance. Of course both would later turn up together in one
- of the first DS9 episodes "Q-Less". Clive Revill (from the Empire
- Strikes Back and Batman: The Animated Series) also stars as Sir Guy.
-
- All of the main cast and the guest cast handle the comedy really well
- and there are some wonderfully comedic moments. The only criticism I
- have is that in the final climatic battle all of the male crew
- members fight with swords or staffs whilst Crusher and Troi are
- reduced to hitting people over the head with earthenware! You would
- have thought that Behr and Russell would have realised that Crusher
- and Troi are equal in all aspects to their male counterparts.
-
- I was always of the opinion that the Next Generation's comedic
- episodes never really stood up to repeat viewing. I still think that
- that is true, but there are aspects of Qpid that wear rather well
- (and some that don't!).
-
- Best moment: Worf breaking Geordi's mandolin.
-
- Man of the moment: Jonathan Frakes (injured whilst filming).
-
- Best line: "Sir! I protest! I am not a merry man!"
-
- Rating: Good
-
-
- Episode Twenty One - "The Drumhead"
- -----------------------------------
-
- Written by Jeri Taylor
- Directed by Jonathan Frakes
-
- Airdate: 29/4/91
-
- Stardate: 44769.2
-
- Guest cast: Sabin - Bruce French
- Simon Tarses - Spencer Garrett
- Admiral Satie - Jean Simmons
-
- An explosion on the Enterprise leads to an investigation by retired
- Admiral Satie. But it soon takes on sinister overtones...
-
- The first thing to be said about this episode is that it has quality
- written all the way through it. Patrick Stewart, Jean Simmons and
- Spencer Garrett are all exceptional as is the directorial outing and
- second episode of the the season. Frakes must be the best director of
- Trek on the small screen and if the powers that be have any sense
- they will let him helm the next movie (if there is one of course).
-
- It can also be derived from "The Drumhead" that the officer exchange
- programme, first seen in the second season episode "A Matter of
- Honor" is still going on and that thirty nine ships and almost 11,000
- lives were lost at the battle of Wolf 359. The actual battle or at
- least part of it would be seen in the teaser to the DS9 pilot
- "Emissary".
-
- However, there is something a little worrying about "Drumhead". The
- same sickness that would later run through such episodes as "Ensign
- Ro" and "The Pegasus" runs through "The Drumhead". Starfllet officers
- acting like the military, which for the last time, they are not! It
- shows a complete misunderstanding of, or even worse a deliberate move
- away from the fact that that Starfleet is a scientific and
- exploratory organisation and nothing else. That fact stops this from
- being an excellent episode along with the fate of Tarses being far
- from clear.
-
- Best momnet: Satie's questioning of Picard
-
- People of the moment: Jean Simmons and Spencer Garrett.
-
- Best line: "Have we become so fearful, so cowardly that we must
- extinguish a man because he carries the blood of a current
- enemy?"
-
- Rating: Good.
-
-
- Episode Twenty Two - "Half A Life"
- ----------------------------------
-
- Written by Peter Allan Fields and Ted Roberts
- Directed by Les Landau
-
- Airdate: 6/5/91
-
- Stardate: 44805.3
-
- Guest cast: Lwaxana Troi - Majel Barrett
- Dara - Michelle Forbes
- O'Brien - Colm Meaney
- Mr. Homn - Carel Struyken
- Dr. Timicen - David Ogden Stiers
-
- Lwaxana Troi is visiting the Enterprise but Picard is safe as this
- time she has her eyes set on a scientist who is on board the ship to
- try and save his dying planet...
-
- Majel Barrett keeps getting better and better with each Lwaxana Troi
- episode. "Half A Life" is easily her strongest up to this point, with
- powerful performances from both her and David Ogden Stiers. Majel
- deftly handles the change from comedy to tradegy and it's her ability
- to do this so well that makes the character she plays so endearing.
-
- Michelle Forbes makes her first Star Trek appearance as Timicen's
- daughter, Dara. She would return in the following season as Ro Laren
- before leaving to pursue a movie career and appearing for one episode
- in each of the sixth and seventh seasons.
-
- This would also see the last appearance as Carel Struyken as Mr.
- Homn. Although he would be mentioned as recently as the seventh
- season's "Dark Page" it seems a pity that he wouldn't be seen again.
-
- Best moment: Any scene with Majel in.
-
- Woman of the moment: Majel Barrett.
-
- Best line: "I know you mother, and believe me you'll never be one of
- those people who die before their time."
-
- Rating: Very good.
-
-
- Episode Twenty Three - "The Host"
- ---------------------------------
-
- Written by Michael Horvat
- Directed by Marvin V. Rush
-
- Airdate: 13/5/91
-
- Stardate: 44821.3
-
- Guest cast: Odan - Franc Luz
- Nurse Ogawa - Patti Yasutake
-
- Doctor Crusher falls in love with a visiting ambassador, but not all
- is what it seems...
-
- The first time that I watched this episode is when I reviewed it for
- this article and I have to say I'm glad it was. This was the first
- real Crusher episode since the beginning og the season and "Remember
- Me". She had had her moments in other episodes and quite frankly was
- better served by them than by this. All this is, or at least it seems
- to be, is forty five minutes of Beverly trying to decide whether she
- loves the Trill symbiont or not. There is no real substance to it.
-
- Yes, we do see more of the hairdresser/beauty salon, but do we really
- need to? It strikes me as rather insulting to women why, to portray
- Doctor Crusher and in an extremely embarrasing scene, Deanna Troi as
- well, as only being concerned with how look and who is going out with
- who. Of course there is a social aspect to their life but its been
- written alot better than this.
-
- Of course we get a first look at a trill in this episode. The Trills
- seen in DS9 are radically different, and apparantly have no trouble
- using the transporters. However with a little stretch of the
- imagination the two episodes are compatible. It never states that the
- Trills have not been encountered before (only that little is known
- about them) or that the transporters treat the symbionts as parasites
- (only that they would harm them) Besides it can be assumed that the
- transporters can be modified.
-
- The worst thing about "The Host" is the rather ludicrous ending. I
- mean just what is the point? It only serves to solve the problem of
- Crusher being attracted to the symbiont and thus not available.
- Completely pointless.
-
- Best moment: When the first host is dying, and the symbiont is
- discovered.
-
- Woman of the moment: Gates McFadden.
-
- Best line: "You can't be open to love if you don't risk pain."
-
- Rating: Awful.
-
-
- Episode Twenty Four - "The Mind's Eye"
- --------------------------------------
-
- Written by Rene Echevarria and Ken Schafer
- Directed by David Livingston
-
- Airdate: 27/5/91
-
- Stardate: 44885.5
-
- Guest cast: Ambassador Kell - Larry Dobkin
- Governer Vagh - Edward Wiley
- O'Brien - Colm Meaney
-
- La Forge is kidnapped by Romulans and programmed to murder an
- important Klingon dignitary...
-
- Borrowing its basic premise from "The Manchurian Candidate" this was
- the prologue to "Redemption". The third Geordi episode of the the
- seasonoffered the viewer the first chance since the first season
- "Heart of Glory" (which in one of those funny coincidences was also a
- Klingon episode) to see the world through Geordi's Visor. A phaser
- rifle and both the Klingon and Romulan transporter beams all make
- their debuts in Next Generation Trek and, along with the splendid
- Klingon makeup and costumes add up to make a sumptuous episode.
-
- The idea of Geordi being kidnapped and then modifications beeing made
- to his Visor is also used in the latest Star Trek movie
- "Generations". Indeed, Geordi's interrogation sequence in
- "Generations" looks (from the few stills I've seen) very similar to
- the reprogramming sequence in "The Minds Eye".
-
- Of course, there is also the mysterious Romulan in the background
- during Geordi's ordeal. Whilst the figure was played by a stand in,
- the voice was that of Denise Crosby. She would actually be seen in
- the last few minutes of "Redemption, Part I" and then in the
- conclusion and in "Unification, Part II" She would then return as
- Tasha Yar in the final episode "All Good Things..."
-
- Whilst the conclusion is a little sudden (it could have been more
- carefully drawn out) the episode comes close to being a classic and
- only misses that mark by a surprising lack of emotion in the script.
- Yes the episode looks great. Yes the story is interesting and leads
- to other episodes and further telling of the struggle for the Klingon
- Empire. But none of the regular cast seem to feel any great emotions
- in what is an incredibly dramatic situation. It's more of a curiosity
- than anything else, but a pity nonetheless.
-
- Best moment: Geordi's brainwashing.
-
- Man of the moment: Levar Burton.
-
- Best line: "It seems that Commander La Forge, like many Humans, has a
- low tolerance for watching others suffer."
-
- Rating: Good.
-
-
- Episode Twenty Five - "In Theory"
- ---------------------------------
-
- Written by Joe Menosky and Ronald D. Moore
- Directed by Patrick Stewart
-
- Airdate: 3/6/91
-
- Stardate: 44932.3
-
- Guest cast: Ensign D'Sora - Michelle Scarabelli
- Keiko - Rosalind Chao
- O'Brien - Colm Meaney
- Guinan - Whoopi Goldberg
-
- Data tries to form a relationship with Ensign D'Sora whilst the
- Enterprise studies a dark matter nebula, and get's more than it's
- crew bargained for...
-
- This was Patrick Stewart's directorial debut for TNG. Unfortunately
- he doesn't do a terrifice job on it. He is hampered by a well below
- average script. The premise is not original, Data stuggling to form
- relationships, but considering the talents behind the screenplay,
- should have been a lot stronger. The cast are all fine apart from
- Brent Spiner who seemed to be playing Data as much more mechanical
- that Spiner normally portrayed him to be. Whether this was due to
- Spiner's acting or Stewart's directing, I don't know but it was far
- too an obvious technique to use.
-
- Suprisingly, for a Data episode there is little added to the viewers
- knowledge or background added to his character. His interest in
- painting is seen here and would continue ot be shown in future
- episodes such as "Birthright, Part I". His interest in music is also
- shown in a scene where he plays what seems to be an oboe along with
- Keiko O'Brien and two other characters.
-
- There are a couple of nice comedic moments both involving Data taking
- what people say literally and an interesting b plot (which would have
- been a lot better if it hadn't been weighed down by the dour a plot)
- but overall this is a major letdown. Stewart would fare much better
- with his third effort, but it wouldn't be until the sixth season and
- after "Hero Worship".
-
- Best moment: Data and Guinan's conversation.
-
- Woman of the moment: Whoopi Goldberg
-
- Best line: "Yes, I've heard Data, and I would be delighted to offer
- any advice I can on understanding women. When I have some
- I'll let you know."
-
- Rating: Awful
-
-
- Episode Twenty Six - "Redemption"
- ---------------------------------
-
- Written by Ronald D. Moore
- Directed by Cliff Bole
-
- Airdate: 17/6/91
-
- Stardate: 44995.3
-
- Guest cast: Gowron - Robert O'Reilly
- Kurn - Tony Todd
- Lursa - Barbara March
- B'Etor - Gwyneth Walsh
- Guinan - Whoopi Goldberg
- Sela - Denise Crosby
-
- Gowron meets with Picard and tells him that a Klingon civil war maybe
- about to break out...
-
- "Redemption" brings to a conclusion a story arc that began in the
- third season episode "Sins of the Father". Characters featured in the
- two episodes would also appear in future Next Generation and DS9
- episodes and even in the new movie "Generations" but it bought to an
- end the civil war plot, apart from Lursa and B'Etor's attempts to
- gather funds (DS9's "Past Prologue" and weaponry ("Generations").
-
- I'm not a big fan of Klingon episodes - I'm tired of all this
- "warrior" and "fighting for honour and glory" stuff. I think it gives
- a very one dimensional picture of Klingon culture. However, for some
- reason, and I'm not quite sure why, this episode really grabs my
- attention. Perhaps it is the brilliant special effects, costumes or
- involving plot. But whatever it is, it all has a cinematic quality to
- it. As an added bonus Michael Dorn gives his best perfomance of the
- season.
-
- Indeed, it is difficult to find fault with "Redemption" but there is
- a blemish on this episode. It comes in the very final scene where the
- mysterious Romulan, previously heard in two episodes before, in "The
- Mind's Eye" finally makes her appearance. It comes as no surprise
- that the character is played by Denise Crosby but the moment you see
- her, not only does she not look ridiculous in her blonde wig, but you
- just know that the explanation for her character is going to be that
- she is some kind of relative. The fifth season would reveal the
- truth, but it did marr an other wise excellent episode.
-
- Best moment: The attack on the Bortas
-
- Man of the moment: Michael Dorn
-
- Best line: "No, it won't. But at some point he's gonna want to know
- what it's like to be Klingon. Just as you're learning
- now."
-
- Rating: Very good.
-
-
-
- Well, there you are, the fourth season of Star Trek: The Next
- Generation". How did it compare with to the breakthrough third
- season? Ultimately, it is all a matter of personal opinion, but I
- hope to offer up my thoughts on the season, and maybe, or maybe not
- you will agree with them.
-
- The season had its high and low points. On the positive side, the
- visual side of things such as costumes, sets, make up and lighting
- all improved on the already high standards set by the third season.
- Jonathan Frakes showed that "The Offspring" was not a flash in the
- pan with two well directed episodes and Cliff Bole, Les Landau and
- Winrich Kolbe also proved their worth.
-
- However, the quality of the stories varied greatly. Whilst there were
- seveteen episodes that were very enjoyable, there were also nine that
- were either average or below. This could be something to do with the
- thirty nine writers credited with teleplays or stories during the
- season. It could also be due to the fact that some twelve episodes
- (ie. just below half of the season) were sequels (or at least
- involved returning characters) to previous episodes. Instead of
- "boldly going" they were merely treading water, or even worse,
- repeating themselves.
-
- Of course that wasn't the case for all of the "sequels". Indeed the
- vast majority of them were really good, and none of them were
- actually bad, But it did show a certain lack of imagination to have
- half the season devoted to going over ground already covered in
- previous episodes.
-
- Surprisingly the show only garnered nine Emmy nominations. This did
- not compare too favourably with the seventeen nominations that the
- third season received. As for winners, there were four compared to
- the previous season's five and still nominations for acting.
-
- It was also a season for families and children. Eight episodes delved
- into family relationships (with three of those featuring children
- heavily). On the more general subject of relationships, of either
- friends and family or romantic there were a massive sixteen episodes.
- Some of these elements combined into single episodes which
- unfortunately gave many of them a soap opera atmosphere. In fact of
- the episodes that I rated either awful or poor, four out of five were
- of this type.
-
- Episodes rated either good or very good counted for seventeen of the
- twenty six episodes or roughly 65% of the season. However, no episode
- rated as excellent and nine episodes (approximately 35%) rated as
- either awful, poor or average.
-
- So overall, it was a slightly above average season, but one that
- failed to live up to the expectations raised by the third season. On
- reflection it wasn't as bad as I remember it to be, but it only came
- close to perfection for about 25% of the season. It was also a
- portend of things to come in the following season.
-
- Ratings and Info.
-
- [] Denotes episode number
-
- Awful Poor Average
-
- The Loss [10] Suddenly Human [4] Final Mission [ 9]
- First Contact [15] Data's Day [11]
- The Host [23] The Wounded [12]
- In Theory [25] Night Terrors [17]
-
- Good Very Good Excellent
-
- Brothers [ 3] Best of Both Worlds, Part II [ 1]
- Remember Me [ 5] Family [ 2]
- Legacy [ 6] Reunion [ 7]
- Future Imperfect [ 8] Identity Crisis [18]
- Devil's Due [13] Half A Life [22]
- Clues [14] Redemption [26]
- Galaxy's Child [15]
- Nth Degree [19]
- Qpid [20]
- The Drumhead [21]
- The Mind's Eye [24]
-
- Emmy Nominations
-
- Robert Blackman - Costume Design, Series: Devil's Due
- Richard D. James - Art Direction, Series : Best of Both Worlds
- Robert Legato - Special Visual FX : Best of Both Worlds
- Marvin Rush - Cinematography, Series: Family
- Michael Wesmore - Makeup, Series : Brothers, Identity Crisis
-
- Emmy Winners
-
- Alan Bernard - Sound Mixing, Series : Best of Both Worlds
- Bill Wistrom - Sound Editing, Series : Best of Both Worlds
- James Wolvington / Mace Matiosian / Wilson Dyer
- - Sound Editing, Series : Best Of Both Worlds
-
- Number of writers : 39
- Number of directors : 15
- Episodes involving sequels : 12 [1,2,3,5,6,7,11,16,19,20,22,26]
- Episodes involving family : 8 [2,3,4,6,7,8,11,26]
- Episodes involving relationships: 16 [2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,16,18,20
- 22,23,25]
- O'Brien appeared in 12 episodes [1,2,3,5,6,11,12,14,17,22,24,25]
- Keiko appeared in 4 episodes [11,12,17,25]
- Ogawa appeared in 4 episodes [8,14,18,23]
- Guinan appeared in 7 episodes [1,2,10,14,16,17,26]
-
- Cast members family featured
-
- Picard's : Brother, sister-in-law and nephew [2]
- Data's : "Father" and "Brother" [3]
- Worf's : Step parants [2], mate, son [7] and brother [26]
- Crusher's: Husband [2]
- Troi's : Mother [22]
-
- Neither La Forge or Riker had any family members featured.
-
- Director of the season : Les Landau (for "Half A Life"
- and "Family")
-
- Actor/actress of the season: Patrick Stewart (for "Best of Both
- Worlds" and "Family")
-
- Overall season rating: Above average.
-
-