home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- Comments: Gated by NETNEWS@AUVM.AMERICAN.EDU
- Path: sparky!uunet!paladin.american.edu!auvm!STAT.COM!DAVID
- X-Delivery-Notice: SMTP MAIL FROM does not correspond to sender.
- Organization: Stat Gateway Service, WB7TPY
- Message-ID: <4003VB2w165w@stat.com>
- Newsgroups: bit.listserv.mednews
- Approved: NETNEWS@AUVM.AMERICAN.EDU
- Date: Sun, 20 Dec 1992 09:28:26 MST
- Sender: MEDNEWS - Health Info-Com Network Newsletter
- <MEDNEWS@ASUACAD.BITNET>
- From: David Dodell <david@STAT.COM>
- Subject: HICN506 Newsletter Part 1/4
- Lines: 706
-
- Volume 5, Number 6 December 20, 1992
-
- +------------------------------------------------+
- ! !
- ! Health Info-Com Network !
- ! Newsletter !
- +------------------------------------------------+
- Editor: David Dodell, D.M.D.
- 10250 North 92nd Street, Suite 210, Scottsdale, Arizona 85258-4599 USA
- Telephone +1 (602) 860-1121
- FAX +1 (602) 451-1165
-
- Compilation Copyright 1992 by David Dodell, D.M.D. All rights Reserved.
- License is hereby granted to republish on electronic media for which no
- fees are charged, so long as the text of this copyright notice and license
- are attached intact to any and all republished portion or portions.
-
- The Health Info-Com Network Newsletter is distributed bimonthly. Articles
- on a medical nature are welcomed. If you have an article, please contact
- the editor for information on how to submit it. If you are interested in
- joining the automated distribution system, please contact the editor.
-
- E-Mail Address:
- Editor:
- Internet: david@stat.com
- FidoNet = 1:114/15
- Bitnet = ATW1H@ASUACAD
- LISTSERV = MEDNEWS@ASUACAD.BITNET (or internet: mednews@asuvm.inre.asu.edu)
- anonymous ftp = vm1.nodak.edu
- Notification List/ftp = hicn-notify-request@stat.com
- FAX Delivery = Contact Editor
-
-
-
-
- ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
-
- T A B L E O F C O N T E N T S
-
-
- 1. Centers for Disease Control - MMWR
- [10 Dec 92] Population-Based Mortality Assessment, Somalia, 1992 ..... 1
- Poliomyelitis Outbreak -- Netherlands, 1992 .......................... 5
- Knowledge of the Purpose of Community Water Fluoridation ............. 7
- Tuberculosis Transmission in State Correctional Institution .......... 11
- Availability of Parenteral Isoniazid -- United States ................ 15
-
- 2. Food & Drug Administration News
- FDA Approves Depo Provera ............................................ 16
- FDA Warns Against Hismanal Interaction ............................... 18
- New Food Safety Education Program for Nursing Homes .................. 19
- Sotalol Hydrochloride Approved For Ventricular Arrhythmia ............ 21
- FDA Advisory Committee Recommends Taxol For Ovarian Cancer ........... 23
- FDA Bans 415 Over-The-Counter Drug Ingredients ....................... 24
- PHS Advisory On Persistent Vaginal Fungal Infection .................. 29
-
- 3. Columns
- Chronic Fatigue Syndrome Newsletter .................................. 31
- AIDS Daily Summary ................................................... 35
-
- 4. Articles
- X-Ray Crystallography used to Track Down Viruses ..................... 43
- Sperm Homing Signal Discovered ....................................... 46
-
-
-
-
-
-
- Health InfoCom Network News Page i
- Volume 5, Number 6 December 20, 1992
-
-
-
- ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
- Centers for Disease Control - MMWR
- ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
-
- Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report
- December 10, 1992
- Courtesy of Karen S. Fleming, Epidemiologist
- Infectious Disease Epidemiology Section
- Arizona Department of Health Services
-
-
- International Notes
- Population-Based Mortality Assessment -- Baidoa and Afgoi, Somalia, 1992
-
- Since 1990, Somalia has been the site of an intense civil war that has
- disrupted health-care services and food delivery to a substantial part of the
- country. A regional drought, in combination with the ongoing civil
- disturbances, has further resulted in widespread famine. Multiple
- international government- and nongovernment-aid agencies are involved in the
- relief effort for Somalia. However, security problems in most areas of Somalia
- have prevented recent, systematic population-based assessments of the health
- and nutritional status of local Somali populations for use in directing
- relief efforts. To characterize the mortality of various Somali populations
- and to provide data on major population centers outside of the capital
- (Mogadishu), CDC, in collaboration with the United Nations Children's Fund
- (UNICEF) and the U.S. Agency for International Development, conducted a
- survey (1) of urban populations in a central region of Somalia (Figure 1).
- This report describes two pilot assessments performed during November 20-25
- and December 5-6, 1992, in the towns of Baidoa and Afgoi. Baidoa
- Baidoa is a regional center of the Bay Region of Somalia. Formal census
- data on this city were not available, and population estimates were provided
- by nongovernment-aid agencies. In early August 1992, the estimated population
- of Baidoa was 37,000 persons; by November 20, the town population had
- decreased to an estimated 21,000. On November 20, based on hut counts, the
- displaced population at two major camps for displaced persons (DPs) in Baidoa
- was approximately 5200 persons. An additional unknown number of DPs resided in
- the town itself.
- For this mortality assessment, the DP-camp population was divided into
- seven areas of approximately equal populations (i.e., clusters), and survey
- starting points were randomly chosen in each of the seven areas. From the
- random starting point, residents in approximately seven consecutive huts in
- each cluster were selected to be interviewed. Interviewees were asked
- questions regarding deaths that occurred in the family (i.e., parents, spouse,
- or children) from the first day following the Moslem holiday Ramadan (April
- 3, 1992) to the day of the interview and deaths that occurred during the 30
-
- Health InfoCom Network News Page 1
- Volume 5, Number 6 December 20, 1992
-
- days preceding the interview.
- Mortality data were collected for 349 DPs who were alive on April 3
- (Table 1). From April 3 through November 21, 137 (39%) persons were reported
- to have died, resulting in an average daily crude mortality rate (CMR) of
- 16.9 deaths per 10,000 population. Among 63 displaced children aged less than
- 5 years, 44 (70%) died from April 3 through November 21 (aged less than 5
- years mortality rate [less than 5MR]=30.1 deaths daily per 10,000 population
- aged less than 5 years). For all age groups, the most common reported causes
- of death based on a structured verbal autopsy were diarrhea (56% [9.4 deaths
- daily per 10,000]) and measles (23% [3.8 deaths daily per 10,000]). During the
- 30 days preceding the survey, 16 (7%) of 228 persons died (average CMR=23.4
- deaths daily per 10,000), and among children aged less than 5 years, five
- (21%) of 24 died (less than 5MR=69.4 deaths daily per 10,000). Of the sample
- population alive on November 20, 9% were children aged less than 5 years.
- To measure mortality for the entire town of Baidoa, mortality
- surveillance data collected by the International Committee of the Red Cross
- and the Somali Red Crescent Society were used. Each morning, dead persons
- found in the city were counted after they were transported by truck for
- burial. From August 9 through November 14, 12,255 dead persons were
- transported for burial (37% of the estimated August 9 Baidoa population).
- During this period, an additional 3700 (10%) persons may have emigrated or
- have died and been buried without being counted. Deaths peaked in early
- September during concurrent epidemics of measles and multidrug-resistant
- Shigella dysenteriae (Figure 2). Afgoi
- Afgoi is a town of approximately 35,000 persons that straddles the
- Shabelle River 19 miles (30 km) west of Mogadishu. To characterize health and
- mortality patterns in this town, 19 cluster survey starting points were
- randomly chosen. On November 24-25 and December 5-6, eight consecutive huts or
- houses were visited in each cluster. However, this survey was curtailed
- before the target number of clusters were visited because of security
- concerns.
- Mortality data were collected from 152 households for 1004 persons who
- were alive on April 3. Of the 767 long-term residents of Afgoi and 237
- persons displaced from other areas who were included in the sample, 94 (9%)
- persons died from April 3 through December 6 (average CMR=4.0 deaths daily
- per 10,000). The most commonly reported causes of death based on a structured
- verbal autopsy were measles (28% [1.1 deaths daily per 10,000]) and diarrhea
- (22% [0.9 deaths daily per 10,000]).
- DPs were more than 1.5 times as likely to die than were residents during
- this period (DP average CMR=5.5 deaths daily per 10,000; resident average
- CMR=3.5 deaths daily per 10,000). As in Baidoa, children aged less than 5
- years were at highest risk for death (less than 5MR=9.4 deaths daily per
- 10,000); moreover, during this period, mortality rates for displaced children
- aged less than 5 years reached 12.8 deaths daily per 10,000.
- CMRs during the 30 days preceding the survey remained elevated (DPs=6.3
-
- Health InfoCom Network News Page 2
- Volume 5, Number 6 December 20, 1992
-
- deaths daily per 10,000; residents=3.7 deaths daily per 10,000) compared with
- the average daily CMRs for the preceding 7 months (DPs=5.6 deaths daily per
- 10,000; residents=3.5 deaths daily per 10,000) (Table 1).
-
- Reported by:
-
- United Nations Children's Fund, Mogadishu, Somalia. Disaster Assistance
- Response Team, US Agency for International Development, Nairobi, Kenya. Div of
- Field Epidemiology, Epidemiology Program Office; Div of Vector-Borne
- Infectious Diseases, National Center for Infectious Diseases; Div of
- Environmental Hazards and Health Effects, National Center for Environmental
- Health; International Health Program Office, CDC.
-
- Editorial Note:
-
- Extreme mortality rates commonly occur in famine-affected, internally
- displaced, and refugee populations (1). During the 1984-85 famine in the Horn
- of Africa, average CMRs exceeded 20 deaths daily per 10,000 persons (1). By
- comparison, the reported annual CMRs in the Horn of Africa during nonfamine
- times ranged from 20 to 24 deaths per 1000, which is equivalent to daily CMRs
- of 0.55-0.65 deaths per 10,000 persons (2). The findings in these
- investigations of mortality among DPs in Baidoa and both displaced and
- resident populations in Afgoi suggest that health conditions are considerably
- worse in Somalia than they were during peak mortality periods of the 1984-85
- famine in Ethiopia and Sudan. The CMRs reported in these villages in Somalia
- are among the highest ever documented by a population survey among famine-
- affected civilians.
- Because of two important limitations in these studies, the findings
- cannot be generalized to the entire population of Somalia. First, although
- these studies were designed as cluster sample-population surveys to assess
- nutritional status and vaccination coverage among children aged 6-59 months,
- too few children were present in the sampled households to permit precise
- estimates of the prevalence of malnutrition in these populations. Second, the
- Baidoa survey characterized the mortality history only of displaced persons,
- and the Afgoi survey results may not have characterized all sections of the
- town because the survey was interrupted.
- Despite these limitations, these findings are a measure of the magnitude
- of the famine-related disaster in Somalia. These findings are also consistent
- with assessments of previous emergencies that have documented that children
- aged less than 5 years and DPs are at highest risk for dying. One indicator
- of the intensity of this disaster is that only 9% of the sample population in
- the Baidoa study were aged less than 5 years compared with 20%-25% for most
- developing-nation populations.
- Although the surveillance data based on body counts in Baidoa suggest a
- gradual improvement in mortality rates, the mortality rates derived from
-
- Health InfoCom Network News Page 3
- Volume 5, Number 6 December 20, 1992
-
- surveys of Afgoi and DPs in Baidoa may not have decreased during the 30 days
- preceding the survey, despite the massive relief efforts. The CMR in Afgoi is
- more than two times higher than the rate recorded for the nearby towns of
- Merca and Qorioley from April 1991 through April 1992 (3). Anecdotal reports
- from other regions of Somalia (e.g., Bardera and Saco Uen) suggest that local
- mortality rates may be higher than in Baidoa or Afgoi.
- Measles, diarrhea, dysentery, acute respiratory infections, and malaria
- are common but preventable causes of mortality among famine-affected
- populations. Feeding programs are critical for reducing protein-energy
- malnutrition; however, community health programs that focus on the prevention
- of these infections can also have a major impact on mortality. Community-
- based measles vaccination and oral rehydration programs should be given high
- priority during famine-related emergencies. In addition, routine vitamin A
- supplementation for all children aged less than 5 years (and older children
- if malnutrition rates are high in older age groups) may also reduce child
- mortality, especially measles-related mortality (4). Surveillance efforts
- should include monitoring of trends in morbidity and mortality and evaluation
- of relief efforts.
-
- References
-
- 1. CDC. Famine-affected, refugee, and displaced populations: recommendations
- for public health issues. MMWR 1992;41(no. RR-13).
-
- 2. United Nations Children's Fund. State of the World's Children, 1991. New
- York: United Nations Children's Fund, 1992.
-
- 3. Manoncourt S, Doppler P, Enten F, et al. Public health consequences of the
- civil war in Somalia, April 1992. Lancet 1992;340:176-7.
-
- 4. Nieburg P, Waldman RJ, Leavell R, Sommer A, DeMaeyer EM. Vitamin A
- supplementation for refugees and famine victims. Bull WHO 1988;66:689-97.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
- Health InfoCom Network News Page 4
- Volume 5, Number 6 December 20, 1992
-
- Update: Poliomyelitis Outbreak -- Netherlands, 1992
-
- The outbreak in the Netherlands of poliomyelitis among unvaccinated
- persons who are members of religious groups that generally do not accept
- vaccination is continuing (1). From September 17 through December 5, 1992, 54
- cases of poliomyelitis were reported to the Netherlands' Office of the Chief
- Medical Officer of Health (Figure 1). Of the 54 patients, 41 (76%) had
- paralytic manifestations of this illness; one neonate died, and 12 patients
- had aseptic meningitis. Fifty-one (94%) of the cases have been laboratory
- confirmed: 40 patients had wild poliovirus type 3 isolated from stool, and 11
- had IgM-specific antibody to poliovirus type 3 suggestive of recent
- infection. All of the reported cases have occurred among unvaccinated (n=53)
- or inadequately vaccinated (n=1) persons belonging to a religious denomination
- that routinely does not accept vaccination. Patients ranged in age from less
- than 1 month to 56 years (mean age: 18.9 years). Of the 12 provinces in the
- Netherlands, seven have reported cases of poliomyelitis; the most severely
- affected provinces are South Holland and Gelderland.
-
- Reported by:
-
- JK van Wijngaarden, MD, Div of Infectious Diseases, Office of the Chief
- Medical Officer of Health; AM van Loon, PhD, P Oostvogel, MD, MN Mulders, MSc,
- Laboratory of Virology, National Institute for Public Health and Environmental
- Protection; J Buitenwerf, PhD, Laboratory of Virology, CF Engelhard, MD, Dept
- of Infectious Diseases, Municipal Health Svcs, Rotterdam, the Netherlands.
- World Health Organization, Geneva. Div of Immunization, National Center for
- Prevention Svcs; Div of Viral and Rickettsial Diseases, National Center for
- Infectious Diseases, CDC.
-
- Editorial Note:
-
- The poliomyelitis epidemic in the Netherlands continues despite control
- measures initiated by the Dutch health authorities, including offering oral
- poliovirus vaccine to all previously unvaccinated persons belonging to
- affected religious groups and to other previously unvaccinated persons aged
- less than 41 years and offering one dose of enhanced-potency inactivated
- poliovirus vaccine to persons who are incompletely vaccinated. Based on the
- ratio of cases of asymptomatic infection to paralytic disease for persons
- infected with poliovirus type 3 (at least 1000:1) (2), an estimated 54,000
- persons in the Netherlands may have been infected with wild poliovirus type 3
- during this outbreak. Therefore, the risk for infection may be greater than
- previously assumed for unvaccinated or inadequately vaccinated travelers to
- the Netherlands. In addition, the potential for spread of this poliovirus to
- other areas (including the North American continent) by asymptomatically
- infected travelers from the Netherlands--even if not directly linked to a
-
- Health InfoCom Network News Page 5
- Volume 5, Number 6 December 20, 1992
-
- clinical case--also may be higher than previously assumed.
- To prevent transmission of imported polioviruses and cases of paralytic
- disease in the United States, increased efforts are necessary to vaccinate
- all unvaccinated or inadequately vaccinated persons in the United States in
- accordance with recommendations of the Advisory Committee on Immunization
- Practices (3,4). Public health agencies and health-care providers should
- intensify outreach, especially to unvaccinated persons in these religious
- communities who do not routinely accept vaccination.
- The risk for acquiring poliomyelitis while in the Netherlands is
- considered small because of the excellent sanitation in the country and
- because transmission of the poliovirus has been limited primarily to
- unvaccinated religious groups. Nonetheless, the polio immunity of travelers to
- the Netherlands should be evaluated, and persons with inadequate protection
- should complete a primary vaccination series with three doses of poliovirus
- vaccine before departure. For travelers with a completed primary series of
- poliovirus vaccine, it may be prudent to obtain one dose of poliovirus vaccine
- before departure, especially if extensive travel in the Netherlands or
- contact with persons in the affected religious groups is anticipated.
-
- References
-
- 1. CDC. Poliomyelitis--Netherlands, 1992. MMWR 1992;41:775-8.
-
- 2. Salk JE. Requirements for persistent immunity to poliovirus. Tr Ass Am
- Physicians 1956; 69:105-14
-
- 3. CDC. Poliomyelitis prevention. MMWR 1982;31:22-6,31-4.
-
- 4. CDC. Poliomyelitis prevention: enhanced-potency inactivated poliomyelitis
- vaccine--supplementary statement. MMWR 1987;36:795-8.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
- Health InfoCom Network News Page 6
- Volume 5, Number 6 December 20, 1992
-
- Effectiveness in Disease and Injury Prevention
- Knowledge of the Purpose of Community Water Fluoridation -- United
- States, 1990
-
- Expansion of water-fluoridation programs in the United States has been based
- on the clear documentation of the caries-preventive benefits of fluoride (1),
- as well as resources made available since the 1970s through the Fluoridation
- and Preventive Services Block grants administered by CDC. An estimated 135
- million persons in the United States--approximately 61% of the population
- served by public water supplies--have access to drinking water with
- clinically important levels of fluoride (0.7 ppm or higher) for the
- prevention of dental caries (2). Efforts to expand the implementation of
- community water fluoridation require dissemination and understanding of
- information about health benefits and purported health risks. This report
- summarizes results from the 1990 National Health Interview Survey (NHIS)
- regarding public knowledge of the purpose and value of fluoridation of
- community drinking water.
- Data for the NHIS were collected by CDC's National Center for Health
- Statistics through personal interviews with a representative sample of the
- civilian, noninstitutionalized, U.S. population aged greater than or equal to
- 18 years. The NHIS is conducted throughout the year and has two parts: a
- basic health and demographic questionnaire (core) that is constant, and
- several specific health-topic questions directed to adults in sample
- households. The 1990 NHIS included 41,104 respondents. Respondents were
- asked: "As you understand it, what is the purpose of adding fluoride to the
- public drinking water?" Interviewers coded responses as one of the following:
- "prevent tooth decay, protect teeth, or related response"; "purify the water
- or related response"; "other"; or "don't know." Analysis reflects adjustment
- for unequal probabilities of selection and for clustering introduced during
- sampling.
- Almost two thirds (62%) of respondents correctly identified the purpose
- of fluoridation. Correct knowledge of the purpose of fluoridation was highest
- for persons aged 35-54 years (68%-70%), than for persons aged 18-24 years
- (49%) and aged greater than or equal to 75 years (40%) (Table 1).
- Persons with more than a high school education were more than twice as
- likely than those with less than a high school education (76% versus 36%) to
- correctly identify the purpose of fluoridation. Among persons with a high
- school education, 61% answered correctly. Among persons with less than a high
- school education, 30% believed the purpose of fluoridation was to purify
- water, compared with 36% who knew it was for preventing tooth decay.
- Persons who were edentulous (i.e., had lost all of their natural teeth)
- were less likely to know the correct purpose of fluoridation than were persons
- who still had their natural teeth (44% versus 64%). In addition, persons who
- visited the dentist 1-3 times during the preceding 12 months (66%-69%) were
- more likely to know the correct purpose of fluoridation than those who had not
-
- Health InfoCom Network News Page 7
- Volume 5, Number 6 December 20, 1992
-
- visited the dentist (50%).
-
- Reported by:
-
- Disease Prevention and Health Promotion Br, Epidemiology and Oral Disease
- Prevention Program, National Institute of Dental Research; Musculoskeletal
- Disease Br, Extramural Program, National Institute of Arthritis and
- Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases, National Institutes of Health. Div of Oral
- Health and Office of the Director, National Center for Prevention Svcs, CDC.
- Editorial Note: Dramatic declines in dental caries in the United States during
- the past half century that have been attributed largely to water fluoridation
- and other fluoride therapies reflect the public importance of fluoride
- exposure to human health (1). At the same time, continuing concerns have been
- raised about possible adverse health effects of fluoride.
- Because more than one third of the U.S. adult population cannot
- correctly identify the purpose of fluoridation, these persons may be less
- likely to make an informed decision when presented with conflicting
- information about the benefits and risks of fluoridation during local efforts
- to fluoridate. The findings of the NHIS suggest that misunderstanding of or
- resistance to fluoridation may be associated with the age and educational
- composition of a community. For example, because older populations have higher
- rates of edentulousness and are less likely to visit dentists, opportunities
- for reinforcement of the benefits of fluoridation are reduced (3).
- Efforts to fluoridate water may be subjected to greater levels of
- scrutiny than other public health interventions because fluoridation is a
- purposeful process to benefit individuals that must be instituted at the
- community level. For example, issues involving the relation between
- fluoridation and bone health and osteoporosis are representative of the range
- of concerns raised about potentially serious health effects of fluoridation.
- In the United States, approximately 250,000 hip fractures occur each year;
- osteo-porosis is an important underlying risk factor for this problem (4).
- However, based on reports from public health agencies, the importance of
- results from some recent studies examining the relation of fluoride in
- drinking water to bone health and bone fracture susceptibility (5-10) appears
- to have been overinterpreted.
- To address concerns about the possible relation of bone health to
- fluoride exposure, the National Institutes of Health (NIH) convened a
- conference of experts to evaluate current public health practices regarding
- fluoride (11). The conference participants concluded that there was not an
- "adequate basis for making firm conclusions relating fluoride levels in
- drinking water to hip fracture and bone health" (11), and there were no
- recommended changes in the Public Health Service policy regarding fluoride.
- Since the NIH conference, two additional studies have been reported
- regarding the relation of fluoride exposure to bone health (9,10,12). An
- ecologic study involving three communities in Utah reported weak statistical
-
- Health InfoCom Network News Page 8
- Volume 5, Number 6 December 20, 1992
-
- evidence of increased risk for hip fracture in the exposed community (9);
- however, this study was constrained by a variety of methodologic limitations
- (10). The second study, conducted in Rochester, Minnesota, used a historical
- baseline incidence of hip fracture in a highly stable population; in this
- study, there was no increased risk for hip fracture following institution of
- fluoridation (12). The findings of these additional studies do not alter the
- conclusions and recommendations of the NIH conference.
- The findings of the NHIS indicate a continuing modest level of knowledge
- of the purpose of fluoridation in the United States-- especially among young
- adults, the oldest adults, and the least educated. These findings, coupled
- with conflicting information and possible misinterpretation about safety, may
- hinder efforts to expand fluoridation. Accordingly, health-care providers,
- public health agencies, and schools should intensify efforts to educate the
- public, especially children and young adults, about the benefits of
- fluoridation and maintaining oral health.
-
- References
-
- 1. Public Health Service. Review of fluoride benefits and risks: report of the
- ad hoc subcommittee of fluoride of the Committee to Coordinate Environmental
- and Health Related Programs. Washington, DC: US Department of Health and
- Human Services, Public Health Service, 1991.
-
- 2. CDC. Public health focus: fluoridation of community water systems. MMWR
- 1992;41:372-5,381.
-
- 3. National Institutes of Health. Oral health of United States adults,
- national findings. Washington, DC: US Department of Health and Human Services,
- Public Health Service, National Institutes of Health, 1987; publication no.
- 87-2868.
-
- 4. Melton LJ III. Fluoride in the prevention of osteoporosis and fractures. J
- Bone Miner Res 1990;5(suppl 1):S163.
-
- 5. Riggs BL, Hodgson SF, O'Fallon WM, et al. Effects of fluoride treatment on
- the fracture rate in postmenopausal women with osteoporosis. N Engl J Med
- 1990;322:802-9.
-
- 6. Kleerekoper M, Peterson EL, Nelson DA, et al. A randomized trial of sodium
- fluoride as a treatment for postmenopausal osteoporosis. Osteoporosis
- International 1991;1:155-61.
-
- 7. Sowers MF, Clark MK, Jannausch ML, Wallace RB. A prospective study of bone
- mineral content and fracture in communities with different fluoride exposure.
- Am J Epidemiol 1991;133:649-60.
-
- Health InfoCom Network News Page 9
- Volume 5, Number 6 December 20, 1992
-
-
- 8. Jacobsen SJ, Goldberg J, Brody JA, Stiers W, Rimm AA. Regional variation
- in the incidence of hip fracture. JAMA 1990;264:500-2.
-
- 9. Danielson C, Lyon JL, Egger M, Goodenough GK. Hip fractures and
- fluoridation in Utah's elderly population. JAMA 1992;286:746-8.
-
- 10. Kleerekoper M. 'Please pass the roach poison again' [Editorial]. JAMA
- 1992;286:781-2.
-
- 11. Gordon SL, Corbin SB. Summary of workshop on drinking water fluoride
- influence on hip fracture [and] on bone health. Osteoporosis International
- 1992;286:109-17.
-
- 12. Jacobsen SJ, O'Fallon WM, Melton LJ III. Hip fracture incidence before
- and after fluoridation of the public water supply: Rochester, Minnesota,
- 1950-1969. Am J Public Health (in press).
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
- Health InfoCom Network News Page 10
- Volume 5, Number 6 December 20, 1992
-
- Epidemiologic Notes and Reports
- Tuberculosis Transmission in a State Correctional Institution --
- California, 1990-1991
-
- During September and October 1991, active tuberculosis (TB) was diagnosed in
- two inmates and one employee of a California state correctional institution
- (1991 average annual inmate population, 5421; employees, 1500). This report
- presents findings from an investigation by the California Department of
- Health Services (CDHS), the California Department of Corrections (CDOC), and
- CDC to determine whether ongoing transmission of Mycobacterium tuberculosis
- was occurring in the institution. Case-Finding Among Inmates
- A case of TB was defined by using the CDC surveillance case definition
- for clinically or laboratory-confirmed TB (1) in any inmate diagnosed or
- treated for TB in the institution during 1991. Of 18 cases identified, 15 were
- culture confirmed. Of the 15 M. tuberculosis isolates, 12 were susceptible to
- all drugs tested, and three were resistant to a single drug (one to
- isoniazid, one to streptomycin, and one to ethambutol). For 10 (56%) of the
- 18 persons, onset of illness was recognized for the first time while they were
- in this institution during 1991, for an annual incidence of 184 per 100,000
- population in the institution. For the remaining eight, seven had TB
- diagnosed before imprisonment, and one inmate had TB diagnosed in 1990.
- Restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis performed on 12
- available isolates revealed three distinct DNA patterns among eight M.
- tuberculosis isolates; the remaining four each had different patterns.
- However, inmates with similar isolates were not present at the institution at
- the same time and therefore could not be linked epidemiologically.
- Because of limited clinical evaluation and prolonged time to sputum
- conversion, three case-patients may have been infectious for a total of 7
- person-months during 1991. Other active cases were not considered infectious:
- three were not culture confirmed, six were diagnosed and the patients were
- started on adequate treatment before they entered the correctional
- institution, two were in persons who had no cough and had smear-negative
- pulmonary TB, and four were in persons who had only extrapulmonary TB.
- Of the 10 inmates whose diagnoses of TB were made while in the
- institution in 1991, two had negative tuberculin skin tests (TSTs) documented
- on entry to the correctional institution 8 months before the diagnosis of TB.
- Neither patient had any known risk factors for anergy; one was negative for
- antibody to human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), and the other was not tested
- but did not report HIV risk behaviors. Tuberculin Reactivity Among Inmates
- The point prevalence of tuberculin positivity and the incidence of TST
- conversion among inmates were estimated from inmate skin test results in
- November 1991 and correctional institution medical records. A positive TST was
- defined as a reaction of greater than or equal to 10-mm induration in response
- to 5 tuberculin units of tuberculin purified protein derivative administered
- by the Mantoux method.
-
- Health InfoCom Network News Page 11
- Volume 5, Number 6 December 20, 1992
-
- Of 3070 inmates in the prison at the end of November 1991, TST results
- were available for 2944 (96%). Of these, 873 (30%) were TST positive: 549 had
- a history of a prior positive test and were not retested in November 1991,
- and 324 tested positive for the first time at the prison in November 1991.
- Of the 324 who tested positive at the prison, 155 had no record of an
- earlier TST; for 21, results had been recorded as positive but the size of
- their TST reaction was not recorded. The remaining 148 TST-positive inmates
- had documented skin test conversions. Of these, 106 (72%) entered the state
- prison system with a negative TST and had skin test conversions while in the
- state prison system; for 97 of the 106, skin test conversion occurred within
- the previous 2 years. The remaining 42 persons who had skin test conversions
- spent some time outside the prison system during the conversion intervals.
- Because of frequent inmate movement between correctional institutions,
- conversions could not be attributed specifically to the institution under
- investigation.
- The 2-year conversion incidence was estimated to be 5.9 per 100 person-
- years spent in the prison system. Case-Finding and Prevalence Among Employees
- The employee identified as one of the three index case-patients was
- diagnosed with culture-negative pulmonary TB in September 1991; the source of
- the employee's infection is undetermined. This employee worked as a counselor
- on the prison's HIV unit and recalled exposure to one of the three infectious
- inmates. The employee did not report any exposure to TB outside the prison.
- The employee's most recent negative multipuncture skin test for TB had been
- in May 1989, 1 year before employment at the prison.
- Records regarding employees' current or past TST status were incomplete.
- However, two other employees had documented skin test conversions during the
- previous 2 years while working at the prison; one reported exposure to an
- inmate with possible TB. Neither reported any known exposures to M.
- tuberculosis outside the prison.
-
- Reported by:
-
- F Schwartz, MD, Marin County Health Dept, San Rafael; S Singh, PM Small, MD,
- Howard Hughes Medical Institute, Stanford; D Cashman, MD, R Campbell, DO, N
- Khoury, MD, California Dept of Corrections; S Coulter, S Royce, MD, R
- Roberto, MD, GW Rutherford, III, MD, State Epidemiologist, California Dept of
- Health Svcs. Div of Field Epidemiology, Epidemiology Program Office, CDC.
-
- Editorial Note:
-
- The incidence of active TB among inmates of this prison was more than 10 times
- the crude incidence of TB in California (17.4 per 100,000 population) for
- 1991. In addition, the number of incident cases was three times what would
- have been predicted for a population of this size and demographic profile.
- Although the incident cases apparently were not linked, two findings from
-
- Health InfoCom Network News Page 12
- Volume 5, Number 6 December 20, 1992
-
- this investigation suggest that transmission of M. tuberculosis may have
- occurred in the prison: first, at least two inmates with active TB may have
- become infected at the prison; and second, a substantial number of TST
- conversions were documented among asymptomatic inmates. The prolonged
- infectiousness of the three active cases in the prison illustrates the
- potential for M. tuberculosis to be propagated in the prison system.
- Although it cannot be proven that the 97 inmates who had TST conversions
- within the previous 2 years were infected while in prison, the 2-year
- conversion incidence of 5.9 per 100 person-years in prison probably
- underestimates the risk for new M. tuberculosis infection. No information was
- available regarding the timing of conversion and the potential for
- acquisition of infection in the state prison system for at least 155 inmates.
-
- The findings in this report, as well as previous findings of the
- potential for introducing multidrug-resistant TB into correctional systems
- (2), emphasize the need to improve infection-control practices in these
- settings. State health departments can assist correctional system officials
- in implementing control measures in correctional facilities (3), including
- 1) regular and systematic TB screening of inmates and staff, with HIV testing
- and TB preventive therapy (PT) for those who test positive for TB and are
- eligible for PT; 2) rapid identification, isolation, and treatment of
- suspected cases of TB; 3) directly observed therapy and PT, and rigorous
- follow-up and recordkeeping to ensure completion of treatment; and 4) follow-
- up to assure continuity of care both inside and outside the correctional
- facilities.
- Recent California legislation, supported by the CDOC, the CDHS, and state
- employee organizations, requires inmate and employee TB skin testing,
- requires reporting of results to the CDHS, and designates that treatment for
- TB may be required as a condition of parole for inmates with active TB. The
- CDHS and the CDOC are cooperating in implementing the mandates of the
- legislation. The CDOC is addressing infection-control issues in its
- facilities, and its staff members are participating on the California
- Tuberculosis Elimination Task Force and the Interagency Working Group on
- Tuberculosis.
-
- References
-
- 1. CDC. Case definitions for public health surveillance. MMWR 1990;39(no.
- RR-13):39-40.
-
- 2. CDC. Transmission of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis among
- --------- end of part 1 ------------
-
- -------------------------------------------------------------------------
- Internet: david@stat.com FAX: +1 (602) 451-1165
- Bitnet: ATW1H@ASUACAD FidoNet=> 1:114/15
- Amateur Packet ax25: wb7tpy@wb7tpy.az.usa.na
-