home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- THE ELECTRONIC JOURNAL OF
- THE ASTRONOMICAL SOCIETY OF THE ATLANTIC
-
- Volume 5, Number 5 - December 1993
-
- The Electronic Journal of the Astronomical Society of the Atlantic
- (EJASA) is published monthly by the Astronomical Society of the
- Atlantic, Incorporated. The ASA is a non-profit organization
- dedicated to the advancement of amateur and professional astronomy
- and space exploration, as well as the social and educational needs
- of its members.
-
- DETECTABILITY OF EXTRATERRESTRIAL TECHNOLOGICAL ACTIVITIES
-
- Guillermo A. Lemarchand [1]
-
- Center for Radiophysics and Space Research
- Cornell University, Ithaca, New York, 14853
-
- 1 - Visiting Fellow under ICSC World Laboratory scholarship
-
- Present address: University of Buenos Aires,
- C.C.8-Suc.25,
- 1425 - Buenos Aires,
- Argentina
-
- This paper was originally presented at the Second United
- Nations/European Space Agency Workshop on Basic Space Science
-
- Co-organized by The Planetary Society in cooperation with
- the Governments of Costa Rica and Colombia, 2-13 November 1992,
- San Jose, Costa Rica - Bogota, Colombia
-
- Introduction
-
- If we want to find evidence for the existence of extraterrestrial
- civilizations (ETC), we must work out an observational strategy for
- detecting this evidence in order to establish the various physical
- quantities in which it involves. This information must be carefully
- analyzed so that it is neither over-interpreted nor overlooked and
- can be checked by independent researchers.
-
- Page 1
-
-
-
-
-
- The physical laws that govern the Universe are the same everywhere,
- so we can use our knowledge of these laws to search for evidence
- that would finally lead us to an ETC. In general, the
- experimentalist studies a system by imposing constraints and
- observing the system's response to a controlled stimulus.
-
- The variety of these constraints and stimuli may be extended at
- will, and experiments can become arbitrarily complex. In the
- problem of the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI), as
- well as in conventional astronomy, the mean distances are so huge
- that the "researcher" can only observe what is received. He or she
- is entirely dependent on the carriers of information that transmit
- to him or her all he or she may learn about the Universe.
-
- Information carriers, however, are not infinite in variety. All
- information we currently have about the Universe beyond our solar
- system has been transmitted to us by means of electromagnetic
- radiation (radio, infrared, optical, ultraviolet, X-rays, and gamma
- rays), cosmic ray particles (electrons and atomic nuclei), and more
- recently by neutrinos.
-
- There is another possible physical carrier, gravitational waves, but
- they are extremely difficult to detect.
-
- For the long future of humanity, there have also been speculations
- about interstellar automatic probes that could be sent for the
- detection of extrasolar life forms around the nearby stars.
-
- Another set of possibilities could be the detection of
- extraterrestrial artifacts in our solar system, left here by alien
- intelligences that want to reveal their visits to us.
-
- Table 1 summarizes the possible "information carriers" that may let
- us find the evidence of an extraterrestrial civilization, according
- to our knowledge of the laws of physics. The classification of
- techniques in Table 1 is not intended to be complete in all
- respects.
-
- Thus, only a few fundamental particles have been listed. No attempt
- has been made to include any antiparticles. This classification,
- like any such scheme, is also quite arbitrary. Groupings could be
- made into different "astronomies".
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
- Page 2
-
-
-
-
-
- TABLE 1: Information Carriers
-
- |-
- | Radio Waves
- | Infrared Rays
- |- | Optical Rays
- | Photon Astronomy| Ultraviolet Rays
- | | X-Rays
- Boson | | Gamma Rays
- Astronomy | |-
- | Graviton Astronomy: Gravity Waves
- |- |-
- | Neutrinos
- |- |- Fermions| Electrons |-
- | Atomic | | Protons | Cosmic
- | Microscopic| |- | Rays
- | Particles | Heavy Particles |-
- Particle | |-
- Astronomy | |-
- | Macroscopic Particles| Meteors, meteorites,
- | or objects | meteoritic dust
- |- |-
- |-
- | Space Probes
- Direct | Manned Exploration
- Techniques | ET Astroengineering Activities in the Solar
- System
- |-
-
- The methods of collecting this information as it arrives at the
- planet Earth make it immediately obvious that it is impossible to
- gather all of it and measure all its components. Each observation
- technique acts as an information filter. Only a fraction (usually
- small) of the complete information can be gathered. The diversity
- of these filters is considerable. They strongly depend on the
- available technology at the time.
-
- In this paper a review of the advantages and disadvantages of each
- "physical carrier" is examined, including the case that the possible
- ETCs are using them for interstellar communication purposes, as well
- as the possibility of detection activities of extraterrestrial
- technologies.
-
- Classification of Extraterrestrial Civilizations
-
- The analysis of the use of each information carrier are deeply
- connected with the assumption of the level of technology of the
- other civilization.
-
- Kardashev (1964) established a general criteria regarding the types
- of activities of extraterrestrial civilizations which can be
- detected at the present level of development. The most general
- parameters of these activities are apparently ultra-powerful energy
- sources, harnessing of enormous solid masses, and the transmission
- of large quantities of information of different kinds through space.
-
- According to Kardashev, the first two parameters are a prerequisite
- for any activity of a supercivilization. In this way, he suggested
-
-
- Page 3
-
-
-
-
-
- the following classification of energetically extravagant
- civilizations:
-
- TYPE I: A level "near" contemporary terrestrial civilization
- with an energy capability equivalent to the solar
- insolation on Earth, between 10exp16 and 10exp17 Watts.
-
- TYPE II: A civilization capable of utilizing and channeling the
- entire radiation output of its star. The energy
- utilization would then be comparable to the luminosity
- of our Sun, about 4x1026 Watts.
-
- TYPE III: A civilization with access to the power comparable
- to the luminosity of the entire Milky Way galaxy,
- about 4x10exp37 Watts.
-
- Kardashev also examined the possibilities in cosmic communication
- which attend the investment of most of the available power into
- communication. A Type II civilization could transmit the contents
- of one hundred thousand average-sized books across the galaxy, a
- distance of one hundred thousand light years, in a total
- transmitting time of one hundred seconds. The transmission of the
- same information intended for a target ten million light years
- distant, a typical intergalactic distance, would take a transmission
- time of a few weeks.
-
- A Type III civilization could transmit the same information over a
- distance of ten billion light years, approximately the radius of the
- observable Universe, with a transmission time of just three seconds.
-
- Kardashev and Zhuravlev (1992) considered that the highest level of
- development corresponds to the highest level of utilization of solid
- space structures and the highest level of energy consumption.
-
- For this assumption, they considered the temperature of solid space
- structures in the range 3 Kelvin s T s 300 K, the consumption of
- energy in the range 1 Luminosity (Sun) s L s 10exp12 L(Sun),
- structures with sizes up to 100 kiloparsecs (kpc), and distances up
- to Dw 1000 mega-parsecs (mpc). One parsec equals 3.26 light years.
-
- Searching for these structures is the domain of millimeter wave
- astronomy. For the 300 Kelvin technology, the maximum emission
- occurs in the infrared region (15-20 micrometers) and searching is
- accomplished with infrared observations from Earth and space. The
- existing radio surveys of the sky (lambda = 6 centimeters (cm) on
- the ground and lambda = 3 millimeters (mm) for the Cosmic Background
- Explorer (COBE) satellite) place an essential limit on the abundance
- of ETC 3 Kelvin technology. The analyzes of the Infrared
- Astronomical Satellite (IRAS) catalog of infrared sources sets
- limitations on the abundance of 300 Kelvin technology.
-
- Information Carriers and the Manifestations of Advanced
- Technological Civilizations
-
- Boson and Photon Astronomy
-
- Electromagnetic radiation carries virtually all the information on
- which modern astrophysics is built. The production of
- electromagnetic radiation is directly related to the physical
-
- Page 4
-
-
-
-
-
- conditions prevailing in the emitter. The propagation of the
- information carried by electromagnetic waves (photons) is affected
- by the conditions along its path. The trajectories it follows
- depend on the local curvature of the Universe, and thus on the local
- distribution of matter (gravitational lenses), extinction affecting
- different wavelengths unequally, neutral hydrogen absorbing all
- radiation below the Lyman limit (91.3 mm), and absorption and
- scattering by interstellar dust, which is more severe at short
- wavelengths.
-
- Interstellar plasma absorbs radio wavelengths of kilometers and
- above, while the scintillations caused by them become a very
- important effect for the case of ETC radio messages (Cordes and
- Lazio, 1991).
-
- The inverse Compton effect lifts low-energy photons to high energies
- in collisions with relativistic electrons, while gamma and X-ray
- photons lose energy by the direct Compton effect. The radiation
- reaching the observer thus bears the imprint of both the source and
- the accidents of its passage though space.
-
- The Universe observable with electromagnetic radiation is five-
- dimensional. Within this phase, four dimensions - frequency
- coverage plus spatial, spectral, and temporal resolutions - should
- properly be measured logarithmically with each unit corresponding to
- one decade (Tarter, 1984). The fifth dimension is polarization,
- which has four possible states: Circular, linear, elliptical, and
- unpolarized.
-
- This increases the volume of logarithmic phase space fourfold.
-
- It is useful to attempt to estimate the volume of the search space
- which may need to be explored to detect an ETC signal. For the case
- of electromagnetic waves, we have a "Cosmic Haystack" with an eight-
- dimensional phase space. Three spatial dimensions (coordinates of
- the source), one dimension for the frequency of emission, two
- dimensions for the polarization, one temporal dimension to
- synchronize transmissions with receptions, and one dimension for the
- sensitivity of the receiver or the transmission power.
-
- If we consider only the microwave region of the spectrum (300
- megahertz (MHz) to 300 gigahertz (GHz)), it is easy to show that
- this Cosmic Haystack has roughly 10exp29 cells, each of 0.1 Hz
- bandwidth, per the number of directions in the sky in which an
- Arecibo (305-meter) radio telescope would need to be pointed to
- conduct an all-sky survey, per a sensitivity between 10exp(-20) and
- 10exp(-30) [W m-2], per two polarizations. The temporal dimension
- (synchronization between transmission and reception) was not
- considered in the calculation. The number of cells increase
- dramatically if we expand our search to other regions of the
- electromagnetic spectrum. Until now, only a small fraction of the
- whole Haystack has been explored (w 10exp(-15) - 10exp(-16)).
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
- Page 5
-
-
-
-
-
-
- TABLE 2: Characteristics of the Electromagnetic Spectrum
-
- (All the numbers that follows each 10 are exponents.)
- ==================================================================
- Spectrum Frequency Wavelength Minimum Energy
- Region Region [Hz] Region [m] per photon [eV]
-
- ==================================================================
- Radio 3x106-3x1010 100-0.01 10-8 - 10-6
- Millimeter 3x1010-3x1012 0.01-10-4 10-6 - 10-4
- Infrared 3x1012-3x1014 10-4-10-6 10-4 - 10-2
- Optical 3x1014-1015 10-6-3x10-7 10-2 - 5
- Ultraviolet 1015-3x1016 3x10-7-10-8 5 - 102
- X-rays 3x1016-3x1019 10-8-10-11 102 - 105
- Gamma-rays r3x1019 s10-11 r105
- ==================================================================
-
- Radio Waves
-
- In the last thirty years, most of the SETI projects have been
- developed in the radio region of the electromagnetic spectrum. A
- complete description of the techniques that all the present and
- near-future SETI programs are using for detecting extraterrestrial
- intelligence radio beacons can be found elsewhere (e.g., Horowitz
- and Sagan, 1993). The general hypothesis for this kind of search is
- that there are several civilizations in the galaxy that are
- transmitting omnidirectional radio signals (civilization Type II),
- or that these civilizations are beaming these kind of messages to
- Earth. In this section we will discuss only the detectability of
- extraterrestrial technological manifestations in the radio spectrum.
-
- Domestic Radio Signals
-
- Sullivan et al (1978) and Sullivan (1981) considered the possibility
- of eavesdropping on radio emissions inadvertently "leaking" from
- other technical civilizations. To better understand the information
- which might be derived from radio leakage, the case of our planet
- Earth was analyzed. As an example, they showed that the United
- States Naval Space Surveillance System (Breetz, 1968) has an
- effective radiated power of 1.4x10exp (10) watts into a bandwidth of
- only 0.1 Hz. Its beam is such that any eavesdropper in the
- declination range of zero to 33 degrees (28 percent of the sky) will
- be illuminated daily for a period of roughly seven seconds. This
- radar has a detectability range of leaking terrestrial signals to
- sixty light years for an Arecibo-type (305-meter) antenna at the
- receiving end, or six hundred light years for a Cyclops array (one
- thousand dishes of 100-meter size each).
-
- Recently Billingham and Tarter (1992) estimated the maximum range at
- which radar signals from Earth could be detected by a search similar
- to the NASA High Resolution Microwave Survey (HRMS) assumed to be
- operating somewhere in the Milky Way galaxy. They examined the
- transmission of the planetary radar of Arecibo and the ballistic
- missile early warning systems (BMEWS). For the calculation of
- maximum range R, the standard range equation is:
-
- R=(EIRP/(4PI PHImin))exp(1/2)
-
-
- Page 6
-
-
-
-
-
- Where PHImin is the sensitivity of the search system in [W m-2].
- For the NASA HRMS Target Search PHImin = 10exp (-27) and for the
- NASA HRMS Sky Survey PHImin w 10exp(-23) (f)exp(1/2), where f is the
- frequency in GHz. Table 3 shows the distances where the Arecibo and
- BMEWS transmissions could be detected by a similar NASA HRMS
- spectrometer.
-
- TABLE 3: HRMS Sensitivity for Earth's Most Powerful Transmissions:
-
- ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
-
- ARECIBO PLANETARY RADAR
-
- (1) TARGETED SEARCH MAXIMUM RANGE (light years)
-
- Unswitched
- With CW detector 4217
- With pulse detector 2371
- Switched
- With CW detector 94
- With pulse detector 290
-
- (2) SKY SURVEY
-
- Unswitched
- CW detector 77
- Switched
- CW detector 9
-
-
- BMEWS
-
- (1) TARGETED SEARCH
- Pulse transmit CW detector 6
- Pulse transmit pulse detector 19
-
- (2) SKY SURVEY
- Pulse transmit CW detector 0.7
-
- ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
-
- All these calculations assumed that the transmitting civilization is
- at the same level of technological evolution as ours on Earth.
-
- Von Hoerner (1961) classified the possible nature of the ETC signals
- into three general possibilities: Local communication on the other
- planet, interstellar communication with certain distinct partners,
- and a desire to attract the attention of unknown future partners.
- Thus he named them as local broadcast, long-distance calls, and
- contacting signals (beacons). In most of the past fifty SETI radio
- projects, the strategy was with the hypothesis that there are
- several civilizations transmitting omnidirectional beacon signals.
-
- Unfortunately, no one has been able to show any positive evidence
- of this kind of beacon signal.
-
- Another possibility is the radio detection of interstellar
- communications between an ETC planet and possible space vehicles.
- Vallee and Simard-Normandin (1985) carried out a search for these
-
- Page 7
-
-
-
-
-
- kind of signals near the galactic center. Because one of the
- characteristics of artificial transmitters (television, radar, etc.)
- is the highly polarized signal (Sullivan et al, 1978), these
- researchers made seven observing runs of roughly three days each in
- a program to scan for strongly polarized radio signals at the
- wavelength of lambda=2.82 cm.
-
- Radar Warning Signals
-
- Assuming that there is a certain number N of civilizations in the
- galaxy at or beyond our own level of technical facility, and
- considering that each civilization is on or near a planet of a Main
- Sequence star where the planetoid and comet impact hazards are
- considered as serious as here, Lemarchand and Sagan (1993)
- considered the possibility for detecting some of these "intelligent
- activities" developed to warn of these potentially dangerous
- impacts.
-
- Because line-of-sight radar astrometric measurements have much finer
- intrinsic fractional precision than their optical plane-of-sight
- counterparts, they are potentially valuable for refining the
- knowledge of planetoid and comet orbits. Radar is an essential
- astrometric tool, yielding both a direct range to a nearby object
- and the radial velocity (with respect to the observer) from the
- Doppler shifted echo (Yeomans et al, 1987, Ostro et al, 1991, and
- Yeomans et al, 1992).
-
- Since in our solar system, most of Earth's nearby planetoids are
- discovered as a result of their rapid motion across the sky, radar
- observations are therefore often immediately possible and
- appropriate.
-
- A single radar detection yields astronomy with a fractional
- precision that is several hundred times better than that of optical
- astrometry.
-
- The inclusion of radar with the optical data in the orbit solution
- can quickly and dramatically reduce future ephemeris uncertainty.
- It provides both impact parameter and impact ellipse estimates.
-
- This kind of radar research gives a clearer picture of the object to
- be intercepted and the orientation of asymmetric bodies prior to
- interception. This is particularly important for eccentric or
- multiple objects.
-
- Radar is also the unique tool capable for making a survey of such
- small objects at all angles with respect to the central star. It
- can also measure reflectivity and polarization to obtain physical
- characteristics and composition.
-
- For this case, we can assume that each of the extraterrestrial
- civilizations in the galaxy maintains as good a radar planetoid
- and/or comet detection and analysis facility as is needed, either on
- the surface of their planet, in orbit, or on one of their possible
- moons.
-
- The threshold for the Equivalent Isotropic Radiated Power (EIRP) of
- the radar signal could be roughly estimated by the size of the
- object (D) that they want to detect (according to the impact hazard)
-
- Page 8
-
-
-
-
-
- and the distance to the inhabited planet (R), in order to have
- enough time to avoid the collision.
-
- One of the most important issues for the success of SETI
- observations on Earth is the ability of an observer to detect an ETC
- signal. This factor is proportional to the received spectral flux
- density of the radiation. That is, the power per unit area per unit
- frequency interval. The flux density will be proportional to the
- EIRP divided by the spectral bandwidth of the transmitting radar
- signals B.
-
- The EIRP is defined as the product of the transmitted power and
- directive antenna gain in the direction of the receiver as EIRP =
- PT.G, where PT is the transmitting power and G the antenna gain.
- This quantity has units of [W/Hz].
-
- According to the kind of object that the ETC wants to detect (nearby
- planetoids, comets, spacecraft, etc.), the distance from the radar
- system and the selected wavelength, a galactic civilization that
- wants to finish a full-sky survey in only one year, will arise from
- a modest "Type 0" (w10exp13 W/Hz, Rw0.4 A.U., Dw5000 m, and lambdaw1
- m) to the transition from "Type I" to "Type II" (w2x10exp24 W/Hz,
- Rw0.4 A.U., Dw10 m, lambdaw1 mm).
-
- Lemarchand and Sagan (1993) also presented a detailed description of
- the expected signal characteristics, as well as the most favorable
- positions in the sky to find one of these signals. They also have
- compared the capability of detection of these transmissions by each
- present and near future SETI projects.
-
- Infrared Waves
-
- There have been some proposals to search in the infrared region for
- beacon signals beamed at us (Lawton, 1971, and Townes, 1983).
-
- Basically, the higher gain available from antennas at shorter
- wavelengths (up to 10exp14 Hz) compensates for the higher quantum
- noise in the receiver and wider noise bandwidth at higher
- frequencies.
-
- One concludes that for the same transmitter powers and directed
- transmission which takes advantage of the high gain, the detectable
- signal-to-noise ratio is comparable at 10 micro-m and 21 cm. Since
- non-thermal carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions have been detected in the
- atmospheres of both Venus and Mars (Demming and Mumma, 1983), Rather
- (1991) suggested the possibility that an advanced society could
- construct transmitters of enormous power by orbiting large mirrors
- to create a high-gain maser from the natural amplification provided
- by the inverted atmospheric lines.
-
- An observation program around three hundred nearby solar-type stars
- has just begun (Tarter, 1992) by Albert Betz (University of
- Colorado) and Charles Townes (University of California at Berkeley).
-
- These observations are currently being made on one of the two 1.7-
- meter elements of an IR interferometer at Mount Wilson observatory.
-
- On average, 21 hours of observing time per month is available for
- searching for evidence of technological signals.
-
- Page 9
-
-
-
-
-
- Dyson (1959, 1966) proposed the search for huge artificial
- biospheres created around a star by an intelligent species as part
- of its technological growth and expansion within a planetary system.
-
- This giant structure would most likely be formed by a swarm of
- artificial habitats and mini-planets capable of intercepting
- essentially all the radiant energy from the parent star.
-
- According to Dyson (1966), the mass of a planet like Jupiter could
- be used to construct an immense shell which could surround the
- central star, having a radius of one Astronomical Unit (A.U.). The
- volume of such a sphere would be 4cr2S, where r is the radius of the
- sphere (1 A.U.) and S the thickness. He imagined a shell or layer
- of rigidly built objects Dw10exp6 kilometers in diameter arranged to
- move in orbits around the star. The minimum number of objects
- required to form a complete spherical shell [2] is about N=4
- PIrexp2/Dexp2w2x10exp5 objects.
-
- This kind of object, known as a "Dyson Sphere", would be a very
- powerful source of infrared radiation. Dyson predicted the peak of
- the radiation at ten micrometers.
-
- The Dyson Sphere is certainly a grand, far-reaching concept. There
- have been some investigations to find them in the IRAS database (V.
- I. Slysh, 1984; Jugaku and Nishimura, 1991; and Kardashev and
- Zhuravlev, 1992).
-
- ==================================================================
- 2 - The concept of this extraterrestrial construct was first
- described in the science fiction novel STAR MAKER by Olaf
- Stapledon in 1937.
- ==================================================================
-
- Optical Waves
-
- In the radio domain, there have been several proposals to use the
- visible region of the spectrum for interstellar communications.
- Since the first proposal by Schwartz and Townes (1961), intensive
- research has been performed on the possible use of lasers for
- interstellar communication.
-
- Ross (1979) examined the great advantages of using short pulses in
- the nanosecond regime at high energy per pulse at very low duty
- cycle.
-
- This proposal was experimentally explored by Shvartsman (1987) and
- Beskin (1993), using a Multichannel Analyzer of Nanosecond Intensity
- Alterations (MANIA), from the six-meter telescope in Russia. This
- equipment allows photon arrival times to be determined with an
- accuracy of 5x10exp(-8) seconds, the dead time being 3x10exp(-7)
- seconds and the maximum intensity of the incoming photon flux is
- 2x10exp4 counts/seconds.
-
- In 1993, MANIA was used from the 2.15-meter telescope of the
- Complejo Astronomico El Leoncito in Argentina, to examine fifty
- nearby solar-type stars for the presence of laser pulses (Lemarchand
- et al, 1993).
-
- Other interesting proposals and analysis of the advantages of lasers
-
- Page 10
-
-
-
-
-
- for interstellar communications have been performed by Betz (1986),
- Kingsley (1992), Ross (1980), and Rather (1991).
-
- The first international SETI in the Optical Spectrum (OSETI)
- Conference was organized by Stuart Kingsley, under the sponsorship
- of The International Society for Optical Engineering, at Los
- Angeles, California, in January of 1993.
-
- There have also been independent suggestions by Drake and Shklovskii
- (Sagan and Shklovskii, 1966) that the presence of a technical
- civilization could be announced by the dumping of a short-lived
- isotope, one which would not ordinarily be expected in the local
- stellar spectrum, into the atmosphere of a star. Drake suggested an
- atom with a strong, resonant absorption line, which may scatter
- about 10exp8 photons sec -1 in the stellar radiation field. A
- photon at optical frequencies has an energy of about 10exp(-12) erg
- or 0.6 eV, so each atom will scatter about 10exp(-4) erg sec-1 in
- the resonance line. If we consider that the typical spectral line
- width might be about 1 ^O, and if we assume that a ten percent
- absorption will be detectable, then this "artificial smog" will
- scatter about (1A/5000A)x10exp(-1) = 2x10exp(-5) of the total
- stellar flux.
-
- Sagan and Shklovskii (1966) considered that if the central star has
- a typical solar flux of 4x10exp33 erg sec-1, it must scatter about
- 8x10exp28 erg sec-1 for the line to be detected. Thus, the ETC
- would need (8x10exp28)/10exp(-4) = 8x10exp32 atoms. The weight of
- the hydrogen atom (mH) is 1.66x10exp(-24) g, so the weight of an
- atom of atomic weight n is nxmH grams.
-
- Drake proposed the used of Technetium (Tc) for this purpose. This
- element is not found on Earth and its presence is observed very
- weakly in the Sun, in part because it is short-lived. Tc's most
- stable form decays radioactively within an average of twenty
- thousand years. Thus, for the case of Tc, we need to distribute
- some 1.3x10exp11 grams, or 1.3x10exp5 tons, of this element into the
- stellar spectrum. However, technetium lines have not been found in
- stars of solar spectral type, but rather only in peculiar ones known
- as S stars. We must know more than we do about both normal and
- peculiar stellar spectra before we can reasonably conclude that the
- presence of an unusual atom in an stellar spectrum is a sign of
- extraterrestrial intelligence.
-
- Whitmire and Wright (1980) considered the possible observational
- consequences of galactic civilizations which utilize their local
- star as a repository for radioactive fissile waste material. If a
- relatively small fraction of the nuclear sources present in the
- crust of a terrestrial-type planet were processed via breeder
- reactors, the resulting stellar spectrum would be selectively
- modified over geological time periods, provided that the star has a
- sufficiently shallow outer convective zone. They have estimated
- that the abundance anomalies resulting from the slow neutron fission
- of plutonium-239 and uranium-233 could be duplicated (compared with
- the natural nucleosynthesis processes), if this process takes place.
-
- Since there are no known natural nucleosynthesis mechanisms that can
- qualitatively duplicate the asymptotic fission abundances, the
- predicted observational characteristics (if observed) could not
- easily be interpreted as a natural phenomenon. They have suggested
-
- Page 11
-
-
-
-
-
- making a survey of A5-F2 stars for (1) an anomalous overabundance of
- the elements of praseodymium and neodymium, (2) the presence, at any
- level, of technetium or plutonium, and (3) an anomalously high ratio
- of barium to zirconium. Of course, if a candidate star is
- identified, a more detailed spectral analysis could be performed and
- compared with the predicted ratios.
-
- Following the same kind of ideas, Philip Morrison discussed
- (Sullivan, 1964) converting one's sun into a signaling light by
- placing a cloud of particles in orbit around it. The cloud would
- cut enough light to make the sun appear to be flashing when seen
- from a distance, so long as the viewer was close to the plane of the
- cloud orbit. Particles about one micron in size, he thought, would
- be comparatively resistant to disruption. The mass of the cloud
- would be comparable to that of a comet covering an area of the sky
- five degrees wide, as seen from the sun. Every few months, the
- cloud would be shifted to constitute a slow form of signaling, the
- changes perhaps designed to represent algebraic equations.
-
- Reeves (1985) speculated on the origin of mysterious stars called
- blue stragglers. This class of star was first identified by Sandage
- (1952). Since that time, no clear consensus upon their origins has
- emerged. This is not, however, due to a paucity of theoretical
- models being devised. Indeed, a wealth of explanations have been
- presented to explain the origins of this star class. The essential
- characteristic of the blue stragglers is that they lie on, or near,
- the Main Sequence, but at surface temperatures and luminosities
- higher than those stars which define the cluster turnoff.
-
- Reeves (1985) suggested the intervention of the inhabitants that
- depend on these stars for light and heat. According to Reeves,
- these inhabitants could have found a way of keeping the stellar
- cores well-mixed with hydrogen, thus delaying the Main Sequence
- turn-off and the ultimately destructive, red giant phase.
-
- Beech (1990) made a more detailed analysis of Reeves' hypothesis and
- suggested an interesting list of mechanisms for mixing envelope
- material into the core of the star. Some of them are as follows:
-
- o Creating a "hot spot" between the stellar core and surface
- through the detonation of a series of hydrogen bombs. This
- process may alternately be achieved by aiming "a powerful,
- extremely concentrated laser beam" at the stellar surface.
-
- o Enhanced stellar rotation and/or enhanced magnetic fields.
- Abt (1985) suggested from his studies of blue stragglers that
- meridional mixing in rapidly rotating stars may enhance their
- Main Sequence lifetime.
-
- If some of these processes can be achieved, the Main Sequence
- lifetime may be greatly extended by factors of ten or more. It is
- far too early to establish, however, whether all the blue stragglers
- are the result of astroengineering activities.
-
- Editor's Note: References to this paper will be published in Part 2
- in the January 1994 issue of the EJASA.
-
-
-
-
- Page 12
-
-
-
-
-
- Related EJASA Articles -
-
- "Does Extraterrestrial Life Exist?", by Angie Feazel
- - November 1989
-
- "Suggestions for an Intragalactic Information Exchange System",
- by Lars W. Holm - November 1989
-
- "Radio Astronomy: A Historical Perspective",
- by David J. Babulski - February 1990
-
- "Getting Started in Amateur Radio Astronomy",
- by Jeffrey M. Lichtman - February 1990
-
- "A Comparison of Optical and Radio Astronomy",
- by David J. Babulski - June 1990
-
- "The Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) in the
- Optical Spectrum, Parts A-F",
- by Dr. Stuart A. Kingsley - January 1992
-
- "History of the Ohio SETI Program", by Robert S. Dixon
- - June 1992
-
- "New Ears on the Sky: The NASA SETI Microwave Observing Project",
- by Bob Arnold, the ARC, and JPL SETI Project - July 1992
-
- "First International Conference on Optical SETI",
- by Dr. Stuart A. Kingsley - October 1992
-
- "Conference Preview: The Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence
- (SETI) in the Optical Spectrum",
- by Dr. Stuart A. Kingsley - January 1993
-
- The Author -
- ==================================================================
- Guillermo A. Lemarchand
- Universidad de Buenos Aires
- POSTAL ADDRESS: C.C.8 - Suc.25,
- 1425-Buenos Aires,
- ARGENTINA
- E-MAIL: lemar@seti.edu.ar
-
- PHONE: 54-1-774-0667 FAX: 54-1-786-8114
- ==================================================================
- THE ELECTRONIC JOURNAL OF THE ASTRONOMICAL SOCIETY OF THE ATLANTIC
-
- December 1993 - Vol. 5, No. 5
- Copyright (c) 1993 - ASA
- --------------------------------------------------------------------
- If you have comments or other information relating to such topics
- as this paper covers, please upload to KeelyNet or send to the
- Vangard Sciences address as listed on the first page.
- Thank you for your consideration, interest and support.
- Jerry W. Decker.........Ron Barker...........Chuck Henderson
- Vangard Sciences/KeelyNet
- --------------------------------------------------------------------
- If we can be of service, you may contact
- Jerry at (214) 324-8741 or Ron at (214) 242-9346
- --------------------------------------------------------------------
- Page 13
-
-
-