Day 257 - 06 Jun 96 - Page 32
1
2 MS. STEEL: That was, I think, because the witness said he did
3 not have the numbers of people which we were originally
4 asking for.
5
6 MR. JUSTICE BELL: Well, I mean...
7
8 MS. STEEL: It turns out that it does.
9
10 MR. JUSTICE BELL: If you are asking for the actual figures,
11 I will deal with that question. But what I would like you
12 to do is, if there are other things which you need to ask
13 Mr. Fairgrieve anyway ask him about those, and then we will
14 see where we are.
15
16 MS. STEEL: Yes. I think it would make life a lot easier if we
17 did have the raw data but I will carry on for now anyway.
18
19 MR. RAMPTON: I have to say I do not agree with that, Ms. Steel
20 is trying to make a case which you ruled over.
21
22 MS. STEEL: I do not see how he can disagree, it is only that
23 people can do their own calculations.
24
25 MR. JUSTICE BELL: I will deal with this as a formal application
26 for discovery. But I think you ought to
27 -- who has that those hard copies?
28 A. The raw data is in computer disk format and is
29 contained at a computer at Taylor Nelson.
30
31 Q. But are there any hard copies tables so far as you know
32 that McDonald's actually had which would show what
33 proportion of the 60,000 actually do eat out during the
34 year?
35 A. The data, no, we do not receive the data reported in
36 table format, we receive the data reported in exactly the
37 format we have submitted in AF1 and 2; we have no use for
38 it.
39
40 Q. Who do you receive that from?
41 A. We receive that via our advertising agency.
42
43 Q. They send it to you?
44 A. From Taylor Nelson, yes.
45
46 Q. Does it come in that form from Taylor Nelson?
47 A. The advertising agency receives the data in the AF1, 2,
48 format from Taylor Nelson, they add an interpretation to it
49 and then send it on to us and we report it to our
50 management.
51
52 Q. Just pause a moment. What I put, in case there is an
53 argument about it, the advertising agency receive the
54 information in AF1 and AF2 form from Taylor Nelson, who
55 keep the data from which AF1 and 2 are made. The
56 advertising agency add an interpretation and send AF1 and 2
57 to McDonald's, the basic data is on hard disk at Taylor
58 Nelson?
59 A. That is correct, yes.
60
