Day 140 - 22 Jun 95 - Page 64


     
     1        these are their words and this is their report.
     2
     3   Q.   How did you take it out of the report?
     4        A.  They gave us this and they gave us some backup detail,
     5        with all the wages and what have you.  This was their
     6        summary, their written summary of what they had done and
     7        how they did it.  We did not have editorial privileges
     8        whatsoever.  They wrote this thing.  We did not write this
     9        thing.
    10
    11   MS. STEEL:   I might be mistaken, but I am pretty certain that
    12        the witness actually said earlier that this was compiled by
    13        McDonald's.
    14
    15   THE WITNESS:   What I was saying, these are what I call
    16        extracts, and I apologise.  What I am saying is this is
    17        part of theirs -- there is all the detail underneath it.
    18        We extracted or we took this part, the summary, from the
    19        entire thing that had the backup detail.  But there is no
    20        mistake about it: this is theirs and their writing, and not
    21        ours.
    22
    23        As a matter of fact, if I recall, my Lord, when I was asked
    24        the other day about the charts and I said these were --
    25        there was a question about were these TPF & C charts or
    26        McDonald's charts, and when I was asked that question
    27        directly, I said that these are TPF & C charts.
    28
    29   MR. RAMPTON:  I think the confusion probably came from the
    30        question.  I will just give your Lordship the reference, if
    31        I may.  The question I asked -----
    32
    33   MR. JUSTICE BELL:  What I suggest is, by all means, ask any more
    34        that you have in mind to ask this evening.  If, overnight,
    35        you check the transcript or Caseview record of what
    36        Mr. Stein previously said, and if you wish to put to him
    37        that what he said in the past is inconsistent with what
    38        Mr. Stein has just said, then do so.  But I suggest you
    39        check it first, so that you will not just depending on your
    40        recollection.  What I suggest you do is -- Mr. Morris said
    41        there are only a few more questions to ask about this --
    42        you finish that and then come back to it some time
    43        tomorrow, when we have checked Caseview or the transcript.
    44
    45   MR. MORRIS:  (To the witness)  You are saying now that these
    46        physical pages were part of the TPF & C report?
    47        A.  This is their work, not McDonald's work.
    48
    49   Q.   TPF & C?
    50        A.  That is correct. 
    51 
    52   Q.   This is part of the report? 
    53        A.  That is correct.
    54
    55   Q.   This was given to you in a lump and you just took certain
    56        pages to read?
    57        A.  No.  I took the top pages, which was their executive
    58        summary.  Exactly as it is worded here is what I took.
    59
    60   Q.   The second paragraph, first sentence, it says:

Prev Next Index