Day 093 - 28 Feb 95 - Page 69
1 A. Yes.
2
3 MR. RAMPTON: Can you let him have mine? I have got a good
4 copy.
5
6 THE WITNESS: I have it, sorry. I went to page 54.
7
8 MR. MORRIS: 53.
9
10 MR. JUSTICE BELL: He seems to be doing all right, Mr. Rampton.
11
12 MR. MORRIS: Out of 64 tests there was a 95 per cent
13 non-conformity of which 45 was major non-conformity and 15
14 was critical non-conformity, that is in numbers?
15 A. Can you -- no, I do not think you have it right. Can
16 you walk through your numbers again one at a time?
17
18 MR. JUSTICE BELL: I am sorry I said that he did not need help
19 because, clearly -- can you not read the line?
20 A. I can read but you are moving from one number to the
21 other.
22
23 MR. MORRIS: I am sorry. If we look at the second row, it says
24 "equipment disassembly" on the left-hand side?
25 A. Yes, I see the 64.
26
27 Q. Then it says 64 tests performed?
28 A. That is correct.
29
30 Q. Then on the next columns it has minor non-conformity, one
31 out of 64, major 45, critical 15, and then it says that
32 percentage at the very end, 95 per cent non-conformity.
33 A. No, that is what is -- that is where you are wrong. It
34 is not 95 per cent. It is not a percentage number.
35
36 Q. It must be, it is 95.31; it has to be a percentage, has it
37 not?
38 A. No, it is not. It is the sum of the numbers from 45
39 plus 15 plus 61 -- I am sorry, no, 45, plus 15 plus 1.
40
41 MR. JUSTICE BELL: They did 64 tests, 61 of them attracted some
42 kind of attention and 61 is 95.31 per cent of 64. That
43 must be right, must it not?
44 A. I am sorry. This, what it is, it is the sum of the
45 points that they give, they assign a minor but it is one
46 point.
47
48 Q. The 61 is but 61 is 95.31 per cent of 64. 64 tests, 61 --
49 I will use the neutral phrase -- attracted some attention
50 and 95.31 per cent -- let me just look at your
51 figures -- it is three short of 64 which is about
52 two-thirds of 100, so it is about five short of the 100 per
53 cent, if one wants to do a little mental arithmetic.
54
55 MR. MORRIS: Equipment disassembly: That is something that is
56 quite important, is it not, in terms of sanitation?
57 A. That is correct. What it also means is that they will
58 not allow -- once they have this number, they will not
59 allow it to be assembled until it meets all of the specs.
60
