Day 039 - 20 Oct 94 - Page 67
1 opinions that you have expressed here. Do you remember
2 yesterday -- my Lord, this is page 18 of yesterday's
3 transcript; I say that so that everybody can read where it
4 is when they look at it.
5
6 MR. JUSTICE BELL: We will probably all remember it when we hear
7 it.
8
9 MR. RAMPTON: You said this, and again I am trying to read it
10 without making a single mistake, Dr. Millstone. Line 33 on
11 page 18. This is in relation to BHA.
12 A. Yes.
13
14 Q. "Now, given that human beings do not consume BHA at those
15 levels", that is to say, high dosage, "and given that it
16 might possibly be the case that the symptoms that were
17 exhibited by those laboratory animals arose by some gross
18 overloading of their biochemistry, it seems to me the
19 sensible thing to do would be to require further studies at
20 lower doses, perhaps closer to those consumed by humans,
21 but in correspondingly larger groups of rodents which might
22 more effectively model the effects which the compounds are
23 likely to have on human beings, lower doses in large
24 groups. But that is not what is done."
25
26 Do you adhere to that characterisation of what you see as a
27 fault in the work which underlies JECFA ADIs?
28 A. Yes, indeed.
29
30 Q. I do not want you to expand upon it, unless his Lordship
31 requires you to; I just want to know whether or not you
32 still adhere to that assertion, proposition?
33 A. I do.
34
35 Q. Thank you. Do you recall that you said a similar thing in
36 relation to Sunset Yellow? My Lord, this is page 47.
37 A. I expect that I did; it would be entirely consistent.
38
39 Q. I am going to read it out. At line 15: "What they", that
40 is this time the Committee on Toxicity, "did not do is ask
41 for further studies at lower doses in larger groups, which
42 I would have thought would be an appropriate way of trying
43 to clarify the issue." It is the same point.
44 A. Yes, indeed.
45
46 Q. Can I ask you to find, if you can -- I do not know if you
47 have Professor Walker's references there; they are in a
48 bundle with an orange label on it -- IV Nutrition. It
49 should have "Walker" and "Arnott" on the back. You want
50 the first part of that, please, at tab 10.
51 A. This is JECFA Report series 24.
52
53 Q. That is right. This is an extract.
54 A. Which page?
55
56 Q. I want you to turn up tab J. You will see it is series 24,
57 Toxicological Evaluation of Certain Food Additives and
58 Contaminants. It is JECFA, as you say. It comes out in
59 1989. I would like you turn to the page stamped at the
60 bottom 258, please?
